Re:YC will hold interviews in Vancouver for founders who can...
by ythn on Thursday March 09, 2017 @07:18PM
(#13835168)
> And your quote isn't even so horrible. Pointing out problems with a particular point of view if new can be enormously insightful and helpful.
From what I see it just becomes a back and forth though that reaches no consensus.
"UBI will solve all of our problems"
"The problem with UBI is X"
"The problem with X is Y, so X isn't really a problem with UBI"
"The problem with Y is Z, so Y is not a problem and X is a problem after all"
"The problem with Z is..."
Re:YC will hold interviews in Vancouver for founders who can...
by wfo on Thursday March 09, 2017 @07:34PM
(#13835267)
Consensus isn't a reasonable goal or even desirable when you're discussing things which are more complex than, say, cut and dried technical facts. I can achieve consensus among mathematicians by providing a proof. I can achieve consensus among scientists by performing repeated experiments. I can achieve consensus among philosophers by, well, killing all the other philosophers. But if I don't do that, I can learn a lot and better develop my own positions and thoughts by having discussions with them even if I'll never force them to agree with me.
You don't have to particularly care for 'soft' discussion and reasoning, but that's not a problem with it, it's a personal preference of yours which is extremely uncommon among the general population, however over represented it is on HN. Every discussion about anything nontechnical has this 'soft' property.
There isn't a correct answer in humanities/politics but that doesn't stop some answers from being very bad, and some answers being better than others, or from some answers being interesting and insightful and valuable regardless of how 'correct' they are.
There's definitely a range of quality in politics discussions though and the barrier for entry to having an opinion is very, very low unlike technical discussions -- it's very easy for it to quickly sink to the lowest form of human interaction that you're describing -- Breitbart, 4chan, youtube comments, /r/politics, etc. I find HN is markedly better than that almost all of the time.
And your quote isn't even so horrible. Pointing out problems with a particular point of view if new can be enormously insightful and helpful.