News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikileaks is offering tech firms CIA files first by cmac2992 on Thursday March 09, 2017 @02:21PM (#13832304)
I have no problem with them optimizing for impact. But they refuse to admit that is what they are doing. It disingenuous at the very least.

It's not "mistake" if PII is revealed in every single release. It is incompetence or they are acting in bad faith. There are dozens of other organizations that have strong records on this. wikileaks is not one of them.

Re:Wikileaks is offering tech firms CIA files first by problems on Thursday March 09, 2017 @02:26PM (#13832389)
> I have no problem with them optimizing for impact. But they refuse to admit that is what they are doing. It disingenuous at the very least.

They've stated that's exactly what they're doing in several pieces.

> It's not "mistake" if PII is revealed in every single release. There are dozens of other organizations that have strong records on this. wikileaks is not one of them.

Likely because those "dozens of other organizations" don't publish many leaks and especially not in anything approaching raw form - every single leak I've seen in a major paper has been heavily filtered down and distilled into a specific narrative. WikiLeaks just publishes with minimal editing - any narrative from them is completely separated from the leaks. That rawness is what makes them better than other approaches for getting real information out, but it's also what makes them worse at censoring that information.

Re:Wikileaks is offering tech firms CIA files first by cmac2992 on Thursday March 09, 2017 @03:02PM (#13832906)
I'm not sure how we can square, "we are neutral", "we are optimizing for impact", "our goal is to create conflict within the government".

>WikiLeaks just publishes with minimal editing - any narrative from them is completely separated from the leaks

Wikileaks in king of clickbait and creating false impressions of what data they are and aren't releasing. Just look at their twitter account. There are even reports of withholding entire data sets when it doesn't fit their narrative.

I am on board for the premise of WikiLeaks is trying to do, but they have flatly failed in the execution.