News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by jackowayed on Thursday May 27, 2010 @12:14AM (#1382649)
I've thought about his point that lowering the death rate makes the problem of population growth worse a lot, especially in the context of Africa and the like.

"Oh they're starving because they get almost no rain, so that land really shouldn't support anywhere near as many people as are there. Let's give them food aid."

10 years elapse, and say they're getting 7% per year growth thanks to food aid keeping them from starving, lack of contraception, etc.

"Oh, there's twice as many of them now, so they're starving despite our current food aid. Double the food aid!"

Repeat until you realize that you can't double the food aid forever.

Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by fleitz on Thursday May 27, 2010 @12:53AM (#1382725)
"We" won't need to give "them" food aid forever, population growth levels off as wealth increases. Possibly the best thing that could be done for Africa is to end farm subsidies and argicultural tarrifs in the developed world.

Here is a great link to the farm subsidies recieved in Manhattan, it's odd how one never notices the wealth of family farms surrounding central park. http://wildgreenyonder.wordpress.com/2007/10/

Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by bryanh on Thursday May 27, 2010 @01:41AM (#1382800)
Though this is logically sound, the core issue remains. Are we to tell them a little starving and death now is good for you in the long run? I think it is extremely interesting to ponder where lines of morality lay on issues like this.
Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by fleitz on Thursday May 27, 2010 @03:19AM (#1382959)
The first step to answering that question is to start thinking of Africa as a continent full of individuals rather than through terms like "us" and "them".

Most answers in the affirmative involve a lot of rationalization and dehumanization and in the modern world likely some kind of starvation default swap sold by a financial institution.

We're all individuals sharing this planet. We are not our government(s). (Unless you're a head of state, then maybe)

Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by pbhjpbhj on Thursday May 27, 2010 @10:58AM (#1383806)
So if a vaccine for a deadly disease is not 100% safe then you wouldn't use it at all as actively killing 1% is worse than passively allowing 80% (say) to die?

When making considerations of the well being of whole populations one has to consider the whole population not the individual.

A decision to withhold food aid now might kill 10%, but supplying that food and buoying up the population until the next big crisis is likely to kill far more people and could push us beyond sustainability - there is a point at which renewable resources become to depleted to recover. Sure, one can consider that the Jones family will lose their daughter and so we have to send food but this leads us on and on to overpopulation.

Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by fleitz on Thursday May 27, 2010 @04:05PM (#1384792)
I would provide access to the vaccine and individuals could choose whether they wanted to take it.

It actually doesn't lead us to overpopulation. Once wealth & education increases to a certain point cultures change and people have fewer children. Paul Ehrlich went over this in the 60s and then made the famous wager with Simon over resources. I think this Malthusian argument has been thoroughly debunked.

The best result for the well being of whole populations is generally achieved by each person in that population doing what is best for themselves.

Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by joeyo on Thursday May 27, 2010 @05:33PM (#1384998)
I would provide access to the vaccine and individuals could choose whether they wanted to take it.

That actually is a really bad idea from a public health perspective. Generally you need well in excess of 50% of the population to be vaccinated before it starts to provide protection to non-vaccinated individuals.

See:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herd_immunity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_modelling_of_infec...

Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by mistermann on Thursday May 27, 2010 @01:58AM (#1382829)
Well, 1 thousand deaths now to achieve self sufficiency, or X deaths later, where x is likely much larger than 1 thousand.

Not to mention, why the fuck in this day and age is the west still responsible for African people eating? We have the technology, the entire country has been geographically analyzed for where maximum food can be produced, etc etc. It is not a geographical problem, it is a political and cultural problem.

It seems fairly obvious they can't sort out this problem, so whats the next move?

We can tell them where to grow food, and where not to. We have given them Billions of dollars in aid. What else can you do?

Of course, this is assuming foreign aid exists to achieve what it says it is trying to achieve....I can think of several groups of people that would like to keep Africa in the stone age for the time being.

However, this doesn't dismiss the responsibilities of the leaders and citizens of Africa. All the technology you need is available on eBay, how about some charismatic man rises up and convinces you to get your shit together?

Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by henrikschroder on Thursday May 27, 2010 @04:32AM (#1383055)
But things are improving.

http://www.gapminder.org

The GNP and life expectancy of Africa is about as good as it was in the western world around 1930, that's not exactly stone-age, and the situation is steadily improving. They'll get there.

Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by crayz on Thursday May 27, 2010 @02:59AM (#1382925)
We have the technology, the entire country has been geographically analyzed...

The entire country of Africa?

Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by ericb on Thursday May 27, 2010 @11:13AM (#1383854)
Possibly the best thing that could be done for humanity in the next hundred years is to solve the lack of empathy for individuals and groups of people we have not met. I think if you had some friends in Africa that would be affected by your solution, you would feel very differently.

I am not picking on you here--I think this is a failing in the way we're wired that some part of us (including me) can consider tragedy at that scale as a possible solution.

Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by dhimes on Thursday May 27, 2010 @05:28PM (#1384990)
Possibly the best thing that could be done for humanity in the next hundred years is to solve the lack of empathy for individuals and groups of people we have not met

I assumed that was one of the roles of religions, but they seem to have a difficult time getting the idea to stick in the majority of their believers.

Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by effn on Thursday May 27, 2010 @11:45AM (#1383963)
Do you seriously believe that subsidies of western farmers is helping people in Africa? What is the "tragedy as a possible solution" you are speaking of?
Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by ericb on Thursday May 27, 2010 @08:26PM (#1385323)
Honestly, my mistake.

I read something that made sense to me which was that OP was objecting to subsidies to African countries--not subsidies for Western farmers. My objection makes no sense in the context of what OP actually said.

Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by Flow on Thursday May 27, 2010 @12:20AM (#1382660)
Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by JoshCole on Thursday May 27, 2010 @02:03AM (#1382840)
In the video explaining exponential growth it talked about how we would need to abandon many things we deem good in order to avoid over population. This video puts things in less grim terms by pointing out that increasing the average life expectancy reduces the number of children per women.
Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by Flow on Thursday May 27, 2010 @02:19AM (#1382861)
Yes, and I think it's very possible that our energy consumption continues to grow, despite the number of people on Earth stabilizes. What do you think?
Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by JoshCole on Friday May 28, 2010 @04:25PM (#1387542)
Eventually it would have to stop growing, but I don't know if it will cease through foresight or catastrophe.
Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by ihodes on Thursday May 27, 2010 @12:20AM (#1382659)
The trick is realizing that the last 3 words of your third sentence are the most important part of your slightly offensive post. That, and education.

Starving a people until they can eat off of the barren land they inhabit is certainly one way of taking care of the problem. Educating them on the merits of contraceptives, and teaching them how to use their land to greater effect is another.

Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by jackowayed on Thursday May 27, 2010 @12:31AM (#1382682)
It's not as easy as giving them contraceptives. Culture and pragmatism both frequently encourage large families.

For example, farming families have major incentives to have large families so that the kids can help with the farming tasks. So you'll need a China-like child limit or some other way to incentivize them to actually use the contraception you provide.

Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by ihodes on Thursday May 27, 2010 @01:10AM (#1382751)
I didn't say "just give them contraceptives."

That's why education is key as well. People who are well-educated have less children, on average. Look at the US, for example. So educate them, and enable them to become wealthy. Right now, they can't.

Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by pbhjpbhj on Thursday May 27, 2010 @08:23PM (#1385318)
>People who are well-educated have less children

But that doesn't mean that a well educated farmer will have less children. He can be as educated as you like but unless he can increase productivity in some way (access to loans for equipment say, like through Fairtrade) then he still has as much work to do and still needs to provide the labour.

Suppose the education increase yields, unless we're on top of the trading practices then the value falls - everyone's yield has increased, if this means the market saturates he might make less money (perhaps none). If the market hasn't saturated he still needs more labour to gather the increased yield but gets the same income to share amongst the labourers - increasing the pressure to provide cheap labour by expanding his family.

In short the problem is more complex and IMO is not due to lack of education. What you're saying is that a poor agricultural labourer should sacrifice there own ability to earn more in order to stave off over-population - why is it down to them.

I'll go with the converse though. If you ensure that workers get a fair wage (Fairtrade again), one that can pay basic healthcare and education costs and ensure they have healthy food intake and a reasonable dwelling, then there is less pressure to reproduce (but possibly more opportunity to choose to? again it's complex).

Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by mistermann on Thursday May 27, 2010 @01:54AM (#1382824)
Africa is not a barren land, much of Africa is perfect for farming. Much of Africa is not "perfect" for farming, but well good enough. However, if you have external nations bringing you food for free, why the hell would you go through the trouble to grow a crop, it's seriously hard work!

And, if you're in the part of Africa where growing crops is not feasible....move?

Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by skybrian on Thursday May 27, 2010 @02:40AM (#1382894)
You realize that this isn't about renting a U-haul, right? It's about traveling, on foot or by public transportation, to somewhere where you don't own any land, don't speak the language, and don't know anyone. In other words, to become a refugee. There are plenty of people like that already, but they tend to move to the cities.
Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by iamwil on Thursday May 27, 2010 @02:18AM (#1382857)
To add, there are unstable places in parts of Africa with civil wars that displace people into refugee camps where they can't do much farming.
Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by wendroid on Thursday May 27, 2010 @01:52AM (#1382818)
I'm not offended by "them food aid."
Re:Our greatest shortcoming is our inability to understand t... by derefr on Thursday May 27, 2010 @12:26AM (#1382671)
Then send them yams and pomegranates. ;)

(For those unaware, they both contain progesterone; wild yams were the first plant to be used in synthesis of birth control pills.)