News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: If the bots take your job, what would you do? by antisthenes on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @04:14PM (#13814957)
Why do you hate communism? Is there a legitimate reason?
Re:Ask HN: If the bots take your job, what would you do? by knieveltech on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @04:41PM (#13815231)
Given his statement I'm assuming his family fled a particular implementation of communism at some point in the past. I struggle with responses to statements like OP has made for a number of reasons. I find it questionable that authoritarianism is a required component of a communist society. That said it has clearly been a component of all implementations of "communism" at the national level. I'm air quoting that because again it's questionable that authoritarian regimes bear any resemblance to actual ML political theory, and most real world implementations were merely authoritarian regimes that borrowed the stalinist playbook and enough ML buzzwords to offer a fig leaf during their rise to power.
Re:Ask HN: If the bots take your job, what would you do? by Akito on Saturday March 11, 2017 @05:49AM (#13845051)
The main reason why I stated this about communism is the constant buzzword-like usage of "communist" by too many right-wingers, when they read anything related to critisizing their oh so beloved capitalistic society. I don't follow communists and want to kill them. So I don't despise it like my worst enemy. But, especially regarding communism that actually happened, like Russia, East-Germany, Cuba, North Korea, etc, I stand against those types with everything I am. And honestly communism wouldn't be ao shitty if people had more self-discpline and could sacrifice freedom for the sake of a better environment for the majority of people. But humans don't work like this which is why communism never worked without making it unfair and totalitarian.
Re:Ask HN: If the bots take your job, what would you do? by dogma1138 on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @05:47PM (#13815880)
Communism requires a planned economy which requires authoritarianism.

Post scarcity != communism, if we go by the motief of this thread then the federation is not communist it also doesn't have a planned economy.

Re:Ask HN: If the bots take your job, what would you do? by knieveltech on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @07:10PM (#13816572)
I hear what you're saying. I question the assertion that economic planning requires authoritarianism, unless you're being really loose with the term.
Re:Ask HN: If the bots take your job, what would you do? by dogma1138 on Thursday March 09, 2017 @05:03AM (#13828297)
planned economy isn't the same thing as economic planning.

"an economy in which production, investment, prices, and incomes are determined centrally by the government."

https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/planned_economy

Re:Ask HN: If the bots take your job, what would you do? by knieveltech on Thursday March 09, 2017 @10:22AM (#13829825)
And government oversight isn't the same thing as authoritarianism. As with most things the devil is usually in the details. I recommend looking into the anarcho-syndicalist strategy for structuring economic activity for a snapshot of one possible approach to the problem of establishing planned economic activity without devolving into a gulag-riddled dystopia.
Re:Ask HN: If the bots take your job, what would you do? by dogma1138 on Thursday March 09, 2017 @11:37AM (#13830402)
This isn't oversight, this is the government controlling all capital, the market, and every other part of the economy.

Anarcho-syndicalism isn't an economic model, it's a revolutionary model which is the most common problem with the vast majority of so called alternative models to planned economy or the free market.

The models are more about how to get control over the power and influence but are very light on what to do next.

Re:Ask HN: If the bots take your job, what would you do? by knieveltech on Thursday March 09, 2017 @02:32PM (#13832476)
facepalm Anarcho-syndicalism is absolutely an economic as well as a political model. Cheers.
Re:Ask HN: If the bots take your job, what would you do? by dogma1138 on Thursday March 09, 2017 @05:04PM (#13834199)
Once you get the power whilst operating within a free market what then?

How is this a sustainable model?