News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber drivers in Norway must pay back all earnings and los... by trendia on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @02:47PM (#13814019)
This is like forcing bank tellers to pay back their salary to the government because the bank management didn't follow the rules.
Re:Uber drivers in Norway must pay back all earnings and los... by lazyasciiart on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @03:00PM (#13814151)
No, it's not. It's more like the US practice of charging people with a misdemeanor crime for selling insurance without a license, which can be levied even against someone selling insurance for a company . Zenefits employees, for instance, risked felony charges in some states and if the company had continued to do business that way I think it's plausible some would have been convicted. However Zenefits changed their leadership, publicly said it was wrong of them and that they wouldn't do it again. Uber has doubled down and said "nah mate we're cool what are you going to do about it". Surprise, the Norwegians are calling their bluff.
Re:Uber drivers in Norway must pay back all earnings and los... by this_user on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @02:55PM (#13814097)
Except in this analogy the bank would be a rogue operation that deliberately and openly defies local law. And the teller would be someone who knowingly participates in breaking the law. So it's really more akin being a member of the mob.
Re:Uber drivers in Norway must pay back all earnings and los... by vkou on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @02:53PM (#13814067)
Or like making street drug dealers pay any gains from the proceeds of their sales, as opposed to the kingpins.

Which is, in fact, exactly how we deal with organized crime. (The kingpins, if caught, will pay too.)

Just because Michael Corleone ordered a hit, generally doesn't mean that you get to keep whatever he paid you.

At least the drivers have legal recourse, in the form of suing Uber.

Re:Uber drivers in Norway must pay back all earnings and los... by manarth on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @04:44PM (#13815266)

  because the bank management didn't follow the rules
In this analogy,

1. Does the bank teller understand that the rules aren't being followed?

2. Is the teller legally obliged to understand the rules?

If a bar-tender serves someone underage, the bar is liable, but so is the bar-tender. Bar-tenders are required to understand the rules (and ignorance of the law is not an excuse for not following the law).

Re:Uber drivers in Norway must pay back all earnings and los... by frgtpsswrdlame on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @02:53PM (#13814070)
In your simile, are the bank tellers also breaking the law?
Re:Uber drivers in Norway must pay back all earnings and los... by elastic_church on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @02:55PM (#13814094)
you make it sound like that is an unfathomable reality to be used an analogy for how ridiculous the Uber scenario is, except that would be reality.

all banks operate under licensing regimes these days. if a legislature also decided to hold bank tellers personally liable because they were operating without a license personally or their organization wasn't, it would be the same. Does the Norwegian government do that? Well I wouldn't have been able to tell you they did that for taxi drivers there 5 minutes ago. The point is that its not actually far fetched.