News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by kar1181 on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:02PM (#13812114)
Having lived in both the UK and US I find the cost of medicines very hard to understand here. For example in the UK I can buy a ventolin inhaler for £10 over the counter (if I went to the Doctor it would be free). But in the US, an inhaler costs me $60 (with insurance).

Why is it that much more expensive here?

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by lukasm on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:11PM (#13812214)
In UK government has almost a monopoly for buying drugs, so they have a leverage in negotiation and there is a lower overhead with paper work.

Americans subsidize drugs for the rest of the world.

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by FireBeyond on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:27PM (#13812433)
Yeah. That's not so accurate.

Top 10 pharma companies, 5/10 are US (2 UK, 2 Swiss, 1 French).

4 of the top 6 for profit margins (from 43%(!) to 19%) are US (Merck is the only outlier, 9th, at 10%).

4 of the top 5 for Sales and Marketing Spend (both on raw dollars and as a percentage of revenue) are US.

3 of the bottom 5 for R&D spend (as a percentage of revenue) are US.

I think I see a little fat that can be trimmed in the name of our so-called subsidization...

Source: http://www.bbc.com/news/business-28212223

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by SilasX on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @01:21PM (#13813047)
I don't know why you think the home country of the drug maker contradicts the claim that Americans are effectively subsidizing drugs. The fact that the company is "Swiss" doesn't change the fact that it's getting disproportionate revenue from ("subsidized by") the US.

>4 of the top 5 for Sales and Marketing Spend (both on raw dollars and as a percentage of revenue) are US.

>3 of the bottom 5 for R&D spend (as a percentage of revenue) are US.

Say that $1 of marketing increases profits (exclusive of that $1) by $1.01. And you can do it 5 billion times before the effects cancel. In that case, it looks like virtually all of your money went to marketing, and yet there's no fat that can be trimmed.

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by kgwgk on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @01:09PM (#13812919)
For all those companies the largest and more profitable market is the US, the country of domicile doesn't have much relevance for this discussion.
Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by ebalit on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @04:32PM (#13815119)
It's not the case for Sanofi if I understand the table on page 5 of this document correctly:

http://www.eucope.org/lib/downloads/basic_facts_about_the_eu...

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by kgwgk on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @04:57PM (#13815410)
These figures are pretty old. See for example: http://en.sanofi.com/Images/40647_GlobalGBUs_NewGeo_2015.xls
Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by arethuza on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:23PM (#13812373)
"I can buy a ventolin inhaler for £10 over the counter"

Ventolin inhalers are apparently available over the counter in pharmacies in the UK - where does the government enter into that?

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by mastax on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @01:37PM (#13813223)
This part:

> if I went to the Doctor it would be free

probably reduces what people are willing to pay.

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by arethuza on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @03:59PM (#13814812)
But nobody is forcing pharmacies to sell them at a loss so they must presumably be making a decent commercial return on them at £10?

[NB Prescription charges aren't the same throughout the UK and where you do pay there is a long list of people who are exempt from paying]

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by tdb7893 on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:22PM (#13812367)
Fun fact: this situation is also called monopsony (i.e. when there is only one buyer in the market)
Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by DanBC on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @04:01PM (#13814829)
> Americans subsidize drugs for the rest of the world.

This keeps being said, but I've never seen any support for it.

It's probably true to say that Americans subsidise the massive advertising budgets.

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by Chestofdraw on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @01:19PM (#13813030)
> Americans subsidize drugs for the rest of the world.

Complete nonsense. I see this regurgitated again and again with nothing to back it up and it falls apart under the slightest inspection.

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by wyldfire on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @01:40PM (#13813253)
I have believed this "nonsense" for a while so I went looking for evidence that supports the claim. I'd always assumed it was just regional market segmentation that allowed them to change a lot more here in the US.

One of the Quora answers [1] to this question has lots of evidence and ultimately boils down to mostly marketing budgets (drugs are advertised directly to consumers here in the US and not elsewhere).

[1] https://www.quora.com/Does-the-US-subsidize-health-care-in-t...

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by maxxxxx on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @02:08PM (#13813567)
"Americans subsidize drugs for the rest of the world"

Don't believe this one second. It's just self-serving nonsense to justify overcharging Americans.

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by Houshalter on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:24PM (#13812398)
Not inhalers, but here is an interesting article on epipens https://slatestarcodex.com/2016/08/29/reverse-voxsplaining-d...

Europe has 8 different competing companies that make epipens, but the US only has only approved 2. And the second one has to be specifically prescribed or you get the more expensive name brand. And the company that makes it apparently gives bribes to generic manufacturers to keep them from competing. And spends lots lobbying congress to let them keep doing this.

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by jostmey on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:11PM (#13812219)
The US pays an unfair burden to cover the cost of developing new drugs. That said, many drug companies seem more concerned with selling drugs that are barely better than a placebo and have cut back on research efforts.
Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by robotresearcher on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @01:16PM (#13812996)
The US is paying for "ask your doctor about X" ads, which in many places are forbidden. That's just wasted money.
Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by refurb on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @02:30PM (#13813831)
That's just wasted money.

Why would a drug company spend money on DTC advertising if it "wasted" money? Your comment suggests they'd be better off not doing it at all.

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by robotresearcher on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @03:33PM (#13814555)
It's not the companies' money being wasted. It's patients' money.

The nation would be better off without the ads. They create an artificially inflated demand.

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by refurb on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @08:52PM (#13817131)
They create an artificially inflated demand.

Doctors are the one's the write scripts, not drug companies. Are you saying doctors can't tell when a patient really needs a drug?

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by robotresearcher on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @12:00AM (#13818021)
There's a very big difference between push and pull. Why else would drug companies spend billions advertising to consumers?
Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by refurb on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @10:38AM (#13820926)
Because there are plenty of patients who, with the right information, will go and talk to their doctor about their problem?
Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by FireBeyond on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:30PM (#13812475)
Not really. The top two spending R&D pharma firms are the Swiss Novartis, and Hoffman-La Roche.

J&J, despite having 40% higher revenues ($70B vs $50B) spent nearly $2B less ($8.2B versus $9.9B) on R&D.

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by maxerickson on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:38PM (#13812578)
They market drugs in the US though.

(I don't think the 'the US bears the burden' argument is especially compelling, I'm just saying that the country where a business is located doesn't reveal where it gets revenue)

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by FireBeyond on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:48PM (#13812704)
Right, and that's really what I'm getting at. The only country in the world (except maybe NZ, who was in the process of phasing it out, and only allowed it as part of a trade deal with the US) where Rx meds are advertised to consumers.

Even with marketing spends of 20-25% of revenue, and R&D spends of 10% (and profit margins of typically 20%+), pharma has still managed to convince many Americans that they are struggling, and Americans are feeling the burden, of the US subsidizing the world's drug research (even though the two largest researching firms in the world aren't the US).

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by maxerickson on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:53PM (#13812761)
By "market", I meant selling them, not just advertising.

A Swiss company can get revenue from the US just as well as a US company. The location of their research lab won't reveal where they make their profits.

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by jedberg on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:47PM (#13812693)
Yeah but those companies sell their drugs for a lot more in the US than elsewhere.

Basically, because the US is wealthy and much less regulated, drug companies from around the world make up a lot of their costs by selling things for more here, especially since private insurers have to pick up the tab in most cases.

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by FireBeyond on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:50PM (#13812725)
When a quarter of their revenue goes on sales and marketing that is pretty subjectively "unnecessary" I don't they can claim with a straight face that it's "subsidizing the world". Especially when they're already making $14B a year in profit, in J&J's case.
Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by cmdrfred on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:56PM (#13812789)
Also if the risk is so high why are drug companies so profitable over the long term? Pharma firms are head and shoulders the most profitable firms in the S&P 500 every single year.
Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by akiselev on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @01:28PM (#13813129)
High risk, high reward. Why would anyone take a higher risk for a lower reward?

Pharmaceutical companies in the S&P500 are so profitable because of barriers to entry, massive capital requirements, and a whole biotechnology industry feeding them acquisitions. Biotech startups going under with zero revenue after raising hundreds of millions of dollars from VCs and institutional investors is a regular occurrence. Since the brunt of the pure research is publicly funded and other investors chasing ROI take care of much of the R&D risk, big pharma companies benefit a lot from other people's money just for providing exit opportunities for smaller companies.

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by drzaiusapelord on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:06PM (#13812154)
Single payer systems negotiate as one. US insurers negotiate as separate entities, so you'll get a better rate with single-payer as its a more powerful negotiator, have less waste, and better outcomes.

Why Trump supporters think they can have the benefits of single-payer while attacking it and proposing a ridiculous healthcare bill is beyond me.

Re:Trump Sends Pharma Stocks Down with New Tweet on Drug Prices by maxerickson on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:36PM (#13812563)
Corporatism.