News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by ghshephard on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @08:43AM (#13810211)
You might put yourself in a worse position if the court compels you to produce the data, but now you can't. You better be very certain that you are able to prove that you deleted the data prior to any notice, or you might find yourself in for a long jail stay.

This is what a lot of people overlook - when the court compels you to produce evidence, or ill gotten gains, saying ,"I can't" - isn't a legal defense.

Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by koolba on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @08:51AM (#13810264)
> This is what a lot of people overlook - when the court compels you to produce evidence, or ill gotten gains, saying ,"I can't" - isn't a legal defense.

We're getting closer and closer to testing that. IANAL but I'd imagine that some combination of the 4th and 5th amendments should cover that situation. The onus would be upon the prosecutor to prove that you destroyed the evidence after the fact.

As a general rule, one does not have to prove they didn't commit a crime, the prosecutor has to prove that they did. Where this gets murky is if a judge orders you to present the non-existent data as contempt of court may apply.

Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by ghshephard on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @02:43PM (#13813973)
There's lots of case history where people are faced with a court order compelling them to return ill-gotten gains, and when they claim "I can't do it, I don't have the money." - they are found guilty of contempt of court if the court believes otherwise. Burden of evidence is not on the court to prove you do have the money, just as in this case, the burden wouldn't be on them to prove you can retrieve the data....
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by rayiner on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @09:34AM (#13810574)
It depends. If you delete all data after a year pursuant to a well established practice, the court should not be able to hold you in contempt. But if your explanation smacks of destruction of evidence, then you've got a problem. Remember, it's not about what you did, in fact (the judge and the prosecutor can't know that). It's about what the circumstantial suggests you did.
Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by saycheese on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @10:26AM (#13811004)
Just to be clear, my assumption was the jurisdiction was US federal law, the entity deleting the data was an individual, the data was their data, and the systems deleting the data were owned by them; this based on the context as I understood it provided by the comment I replied to of this thread.

As such, would you please explain why you provide a timeframe for keeping the data prior to deleting it?

Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by scotch_drinker on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @11:17AM (#13811563)
I think he's saying "If you have a policy of deleting your data older than X, you are OK." You have to be able to prove that well before being asked for the data, you had a policy that resulted in it being deleted.

Where I work, we delete emails older than 6 months as a company policy. I have to assume this is done for exactly this reason. Don't ask why we might want to do that, I'm not in charge. :-)

Re:Amazon to hand over Echo audio from alleged murder after ... by rayiner on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @11:46AM (#13811876)
Right. It's about insulating yourself from the accusation that you deleted that data to cover up wrongdoing, rather than for other reasons.