Re:Stock options are complicated
by propter_hoc on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @11:42AM
(#13811808)
The basic reason that investor capital has a liquidation preference is that if it didn't, the founders could raise $X million on day N, then since they hold the majority of voting rights, declare bankruptcy on day N+1, and split the majority of the invested capital among each other.
There are ways around this, such as giving the investor a veto on bankruptcies and reorganizations, but the time-honored solution is a 1x liquidation preference where the investor gets their capital back in a bankruptcy.
Re:Stock options are complicated
by prostoalex on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @01:35AM
(#13808680)
I'd go with Occam's razor on this - investors always want preferred, the more preferences the merrier, companies always want to sell common, and if they could go sub-common (by stripping the shares of voting rights or dividend participation) they would.
Whoever has the most leverage in the transaction tends to win.
I think in an ideal world, investors would normally receive common stock (and more of it), but there are some practical reasons why that isn't the case:
- Selling preferred stock lets a company declare a more lofty valuation.
- If a company sold common stock to investors, they'd have to use the more realistic fundraising valuation when pricing options, rather than a (typically) more conservative 409a price.
- Employees tend to not have access to the cap table, or not understand it, so there's not much disadvantage to giving them less favorable terms.