News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UC Berkeley to remove public legacy libraries by phozy1 on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:41AM (#13808508)
I'm lost. why not just run the content through a modern voice to text API? They are pretty good and youtube has their own voice to text captions, right?
Re:UC Berkeley to remove public legacy libraries by Rebelgecko on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:59AM (#13808567)
The complaint that Cal got said that the autogenerated Youtube captions were inaccurate enough to be considered discriminatory.
Re:UC Berkeley to remove public legacy libraries by cbhl on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @12:52AM (#13808543)
I actually think there is room for a "human-assisted collaborative captioning" effort. You'd start with the results of automated speech recognition, and then you'd add in Google Docs-style collaborative editing of the closed captioning / fan subs.

Imagine if you could save a video by watching it and correcting the typos in the existing transcript.

But there's no way it'd be a viable business. (That's Rev, and it costs $1/minute, and it doesn't even give you a .srt file that you can upload to YouTube.)

Plus, you'd have to deal with spam/abuse, and creative uses of captions (e.g. niconico).

I tried building a prototype of this in college, but I couldn't figure out how to make it work financially, so I had to take a paid summer internship at YouTube.

Re:UC Berkeley to remove public legacy libraries by ericras on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @01:08AM (#13808599)
This has existed for years: http://amara.org/
Re:UC Berkeley to remove public legacy libraries by cbhl on Wednesday March 08, 2017 @05:48PM (#13824674)
To put it lightly, the Amara platform needs work. If you try to sign in with both Google and Facebook and the same e-mail address, you end up creating two separate accounts that are impossible to link/merge. Never mind that people have multiple email addresses and phone numbers and YouTube accounts in real life.

If it has existed for years, why wasn't it used to save the UC Berkeley library videos?

I'm thinking more of a Google Docs style interface, where you can make a lightweight edit (only one or two lines of captions) and someone else can concurrently time and edit other lines.

Re:UC Berkeley to remove public legacy libraries by wazanator on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @02:17AM (#13808816)
From what I have been able to gather reading on various sites the courts are fairly strict about the accuracy of closed captions. While YouTube's auto captions are good they don't have a high enough accuracy. Google even says you need to provide your own closed captions if you plan to stream a live event that will appear on TV. https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/3068031?hl=en
Re:UC Berkeley to remove public legacy libraries by oculusthrift on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @02:19AM (#13808820)
Captioning alone was projected to cost a million dollars and that wasn't the only problem. "OOC media content was riddled with accessibility issues including low-color contrast, missing and screen reader accessibility issues"

So even though it's free, somehow they have to take it down and ruin it for everyone.