News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wired's iPad edition arrives, converted from Flash by Adobe by jcl on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @12:15PM (#1380637)
So we have:

Translated from Flash to Objective-C by hand: OK

Translated from Flash to Objective-C by computer program: Not OK

The good news, I guess, is that Apple is apparently confirming that "originally written in Objective-C" doesn't mean "the first concrete representation of the program was in Objective-C", which means people are free to prototype an app in whatever language they want, as long as they totally rewrite it in Objective-C by hand.

Re:Wired's iPad edition arrives, converted from Flash by Adobe by tvon on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @12:18PM (#1380644)
> Translated from Flash to Objective-C by computer program: Not OK

Assuming you're referring to the CS5 feature, it converts Flash to byte-code, not Objective-C.

Re:Wired's iPad edition arrives, converted from Flash by Adobe by jcl on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @01:01PM (#1380784)
While it's true that CS5 converts Flash to bytecode, Apple's rejection of RunRev's proposal suggests that Flash programs would have been rejected even if CS5 had translated to Objective-C.

http://www.runrev.com/company/runrev-blog/revmobile-and-appl...

Re:Wired's iPad edition arrives, converted from Flash by Adobe by jodrellblank on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @12:43PM (#1380717)
No we don't, we have:

Rewritten in Objective-C: OK

Translated from Flash to Objective-C by computer program: Not OK

It's like the difference between hiring a translator and using Google translate or hiring a typist versus using speech recognition.

[Edited for clarity: meant to change translated by hand to rewritten by intelligent human, and keep the second one the same].

Re:Wired's iPad edition arrives, converted from Flash by Adobe by endtime on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @12:52PM (#1380745)
I don't see how "Machine translation" is any different than "Translated from Flash to Objective-C by computer program".
Re:Wired's iPad edition arrives, converted from Flash by Adobe by jodrellblank on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @01:37PM (#1380914)
It isn't, the change I made was from translated by human to rewritten by human, and the distinguishing bit of that change is human versus machine.

The parent was implying some kind of double standard where the "computing device" doing the change made a difference but shouldn't, and I was pointing out that the human isn't "mechanically translating", but "reinterpreting / rewriting". I just didn't write it out very clearly that the second one is the same. Will edit.