News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UCBerkeley Will Delete Online Content by Turing_Machine on Monday March 06, 2017 @03:42PM (#13805896)
Here is the problem with your "enforcing the law" argument:

Berkeley is not being inconvenienced in the slightest by "enforcing the law". The general public is.

Disabled people aren't being helped in the slightest by "enforcing the law". Instead, they are losing access to material that at least some of them can use.

When "enforcing the law" harms people who had nothing to do with violating it, does nothing to help those who were supposed to benefit, and doesn't really punish those who have (allegedly) broken it, it is quite clearly a poorly-written (or perhaps, enforced) law.

Re:UCBerkeley Will Delete Online Content by danso on Monday March 06, 2017 @06:49PM (#13807166)
The law argues that disabled people were harmed when Berkeley used public resources to publish something not accessible to the disabled.

Again, you have to think more broadly than the specific parties in this incident. Just because the lawsuit was brought by this specific plaintiff doesn't mean that this content was effectively "hidden" from disabled folks that may have been interested in the past.

If this lawsuit hadn't raised attention, then it's possible Berkeley (and others in society) would continue to make inaccessible content. The law isn't very effective if it requires a disability advocate to file a lawsuit before it is enforced.

Re:UCBerkeley Will Delete Online Content by Turing_Machine on Monday March 06, 2017 @08:29PM (#13807628)
"The law argues that disabled people were harmed when Berkeley used public resources to publish something not accessible to the disabled."

But Berkeley isn't being punished. The general public, including disabled people is.

"Just because the lawsuit was brought by this specific plaintiff doesn't mean that this content was effectively "hidden" from disabled folks that may have been interested in the past."

I realize that. However, it seems to me that this outcome is, if anything, making the situation worse. Blind people could presumably get something from the audio content. Deaf people could get something from the video content. Now they can't. How is this better?