Re:We Need More ‘Useless’ Knowledge
by ChuckMcM on Monday March 06, 2017 @12:46PM
(#13804417)
It worked for me, but the summary is that in the past there has been a place for 'pure' research (which is to say not motivated by a particular financial goal and without restriction). The article argues that the good that has come of that has been greatly in excess of the investment and so "we" should do more investment like that.
I don't disagree, and open ended research is really helpful in furthering the good of the community. It is also not possible to predict which means typical economic forces are not present to keep it funded.
I've wondered sometimes if the lottery proceeds would be better spent on this sort of activity rather than public schools. The reasoning for that is that the public schools don't have any visibility into how much (or how little) they will get from the lottery in a given year so they have a hard time allocating funds for on-going projects, instead doing one-offs like new classrooms or some other self contained project. Whereas if you dumped that money into a grant pile and people could apply for grants out of it for research, that might work better.
Sadly, because (and the article points this out) you can't say definitively "this research is going to give you these benefits in 10 years" you can't really say that you haven't just wasted all the money you spent. And that is where unconstrained research gets killed.
Re:We Need More ‘Useless’ Knowledge
by hackuser on Monday March 06, 2017 @03:10PM
(#13805649)
Perhaps public schools should be funded with something more fair and reliable, such as income taxes. (I'd go for wealth taxes as more fair, but that's a long shot.)
I don't disagree, and open ended research is really helpful in furthering the good of the community. It is also not possible to predict which means typical economic forces are not present to keep it funded.
I've wondered sometimes if the lottery proceeds would be better spent on this sort of activity rather than public schools. The reasoning for that is that the public schools don't have any visibility into how much (or how little) they will get from the lottery in a given year so they have a hard time allocating funds for on-going projects, instead doing one-offs like new classrooms or some other self contained project. Whereas if you dumped that money into a grant pile and people could apply for grants out of it for research, that might work better.
Sadly, because (and the article points this out) you can't say definitively "this research is going to give you these benefits in 10 years" you can't really say that you haven't just wasted all the money you spent. And that is where unconstrained research gets killed.