Re:Secure Computing for Journalists
by marcosdumay on Monday March 06, 2017 @12:44PM
(#13804400)
Hum...
> 1) Apple has shown substantial backbone in fighting against the US government when pressed to exploit a phone.
And the phone was exploited anyway. The only thing that was established is that Apple must not be forced to help.
> 2) The other choice is a device made by a Chinese or Korean company with a semi-open operating system made by a US company.
That makes both alike.
> 3) Either device will have a totally closed baseband chip.
This is the one the iPhone got right. On the iPhones, it is insulated by a closed interface.
> 4) Deploying and maintaining secure Linux environment on a Laptop is a full time job that requires expertise journalists don't have.
Ditto for Android, iOS, Windows, OS/2, AIX, GNU/Hurd... And anything else you may think about.
> 5) Open versus closed source is a red herring. Everyone is using pre-compiled binaries.
Open source is a necessary condition for securing against any targeted attack. It's just far from sufficient. Also, pre-compiled binaries can help you.
> 1) Apple has shown substantial backbone in fighting against the US government when pressed to exploit a phone.
And the phone was exploited anyway. The only thing that was established is that Apple must not be forced to help.
> 2) The other choice is a device made by a Chinese or Korean company with a semi-open operating system made by a US company.
That makes both alike.
> 3) Either device will have a totally closed baseband chip.
This is the one the iPhone got right. On the iPhones, it is insulated by a closed interface.
> 4) Deploying and maintaining secure Linux environment on a Laptop is a full time job that requires expertise journalists don't have.
Ditto for Android, iOS, Windows, OS/2, AIX, GNU/Hurd... And anything else you may think about.
> 5) Open versus closed source is a red herring. Everyone is using pre-compiled binaries.
Open source is a necessary condition for securing against any targeted attack. It's just far from sufficient. Also, pre-compiled binaries can help you.
Anyway, both platforms are pretty much closed.