News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Need More ‘Useless’ Knowledge by komali2 on Monday March 06, 2017 @12:43PM (#13804378)
"the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, N.J. The institute was the brainchild of its first director, Abraham Flexner. Intended to be a "paradise for scholars" with no students or administrative duties, it allowed its academic stars to fully concentrate on deep thoughts,"

I highly recommend reading "Anathem" by Neal Stephenson. The basic premise is there are institutions known as "Maths" that are essentially walled temples, the gates of which only open once every 1, 10, 100, and 1000 years (outermost gate annualy, 2nd innermost decmntennially, etc). Inside, a bunch of monks hang around studying "useless knowledge," which in this universe includes things such as particle physics (there's one "thousander" temple in which the monks just sit deep in a mountain staring at a giant pool of water to see if they can glimpse a flash of light).

I always thought it would be really cool to have something similar in our world, I hadn't realized it's been pursued before.

Re:We Need More ‘Useless’ Knowledge by beloch on Monday March 06, 2017 @01:16PM (#13804698)
In Anathem, there was a global catastrophe of an unspecified nature caused (or at least blamed on) science. Physicists, mathematicians, etc. are segregated from broader society (and high technology) to prevent future reoccurrences of this because their disciplines are viewed as being too dangerous to allow in the "saecular"(sic) world.

A mountain retreat for "useless" science is a nice idea, but Anathem's "Maths" were something else entirely. They were actually quite dystopian.

Re:We Need More ‘Useless’ Knowledge by logfromblammo on Monday March 06, 2017 @04:21PM (#13806164)
The catastrophe (of the main storyline universe) was unequivocally caused by science. If I recall correctly, it was implicitly three orders of magnitude worse than the technological super-weapons of our own World War 2.

Metaphorically, the scientists were then treated like the plutonium pits of nuclear weapons--well isolated, so that they could not form a critical mass and start a runaway chain reaction, and arms-controlled, so that none of them could be exploited by politics.

When the world needed a lot of brainpower, fast, the scientists were taken out of their safe storage and connected to each other using the separate monastic order of technicians, to intentionally cause a runaway chain reaction. Basically, the whole world was already pretty much boned, so the political leaders might as well set off their doomsday device--which was nothing more than to allow the smartest people on their planet to collaborate in real-time. That was the same thing that had previously (nearly) destroyed their civilization.

"Just because we checked our guns at the door doesn't mean our brains will change from hand grenades."

Re:We Need More ‘Useless’ Knowledge by komali2 on Monday March 06, 2017 @04:15PM (#13806105)
I don't know if they were necessarily dystopian. In the book, the Maths survive throughout global wars and other saecular catastrophes. So sometimes they'd come out of the gate and everyone would be cavemen, other times, 1980s style civilizations with televisions and cars. Seems like a pretty rosy situation to me.
Re:We Need More ‘Useless’ Knowledge by db48x on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @06:24AM (#13809611)
Yea, they are a weird mixture of prison and lifeline for civilization. Until they get Sacked.
Re:We Need More ‘Useless’ Knowledge by drzaiusapelord on Monday March 06, 2017 @02:54PM (#13805518)
The maths weren't exactly Hogwarts for nerds. It was a way to keep the other academic disciplines for interacting to prevent another catastrophe.

Also silo'ing off knowledge is kinda crazy. If a discovery in a 100 year math happens at year 2, then it take 98 more years before the outside world gets the research.

Re:We Need More ‘Useless’ Knowledge by MegaButts on Monday March 06, 2017 @03:38PM (#13805878)
I agree that sharing knowledge is a good idea, but it doesn't always work that way according to history. For things that are "pure knowledge" such as mathematics or philosophy, sometimes the true geniuses would rather keep their work to themselves. Newton invented calculus and didn't share it with the world until Leibniz took credit for his independent work. Then there are questions of how often people may have just never shared things (or they just pretended to know more than they did), such as Fermat's Last Theorem.

I think some of the people that are attracted to this kind of work are going to do whatever they want to do, incentives be damned.