Re:UC Berkeley makes course video content unavailable to public
by victorhooi on Monday March 06, 2017 @11:00AM
(#13803505)
My question to you is - what if deafness was eradicated?
Sign-language as a living language might suffer.
But would you consider this a net positive?
An analogy might be if blindness and sight problems became eradicated - and braille suffered a decline.
I would consider this a net positive for human quality of life.
I don't see the analogy between Hebrew/Jewish identity, and braille/sign language and blindness/deafness.
To me, the first is a cultural/religious identity - whilst the latter is an adaption to communicate as best as one can, with a more limited toolset. Of course, I see that it's not that black and white - there is a thriving deaf community, and they do have their own "language" (as in, more than just sign language itself), cultural norms etc.
However, I do really hope for one day where we might eradicate all of disabilities - deafness, blindness, mobility impairments etc.
Sign-language as a living language might suffer.
But would you consider this a net positive?
An analogy might be if blindness and sight problems became eradicated - and braille suffered a decline.
I would consider this a net positive for human quality of life.
I don't see the analogy between Hebrew/Jewish identity, and braille/sign language and blindness/deafness.
To me, the first is a cultural/religious identity - whilst the latter is an adaption to communicate as best as one can, with a more limited toolset. Of course, I see that it's not that black and white - there is a thriving deaf community, and they do have their own "language" (as in, more than just sign language itself), cultural norms etc.
However, I do really hope for one day where we might eradicate all of disabilities - deafness, blindness, mobility impairments etc.