News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mathematics for Computer Science [pdf] by dragonwriter on Monday March 06, 2017 @09:32AM (#13802823)
> What is the justification for a book being priced at nearly $300?

It's a product of a capitalist, for-profit producer. The justift for its price is that the market will bear it.

Re:Mathematics for Computer Science [pdf] by bogomipz on Monday March 06, 2017 @11:07AM (#13803546)
Is that a real market though when it is mandated that I must purchase one specific book?

So I don't think your "this is just how capitalism works" argument holds much credibility here.

Re:Mathematics for Computer Science [pdf] by dragonwriter on Monday March 06, 2017 @11:48AM (#13803849)
> Is that a real market though when it is mandated that I must purchase one specific book?

A real market? Absolutely. An idealized free market, no, but real markets never are.

> So I don't think your "this is just how capitalism works" argument holds much credibility here.

This is, in fact, just how capitalism works, and has always worked, in the real world.

Re:Mathematics for Computer Science [pdf] by bogomipz on Monday March 06, 2017 @12:02PM (#13803997)
>"This is, in fact, just how capitalism works, and has always worked, in the real world."

A central tenet of capitalism is a competitive market though. Where is the competition when I am mandated to buy a single book?

Re:Mathematics for Computer Science [pdf] by dragonwriter on Monday March 06, 2017 @12:37PM (#13804332)
> A central tenet of capitalism is a competitive market though

It's true that a lot of the defense of capitalism that was ginned up (long) after the system was described and named by its critics involves invoking all kinds of hokum about markets which are both free and competitive which not only has nothing to do with anything in the history of capitalism, but isn't even all that internally consistent because of the tendency toward monopoly in unregulated markets where producers experience economies of scale (and in some other common cases.)

But this is a (deeply flawed) rationalization of capitalism, not its foundation.

Re:Mathematics for Computer Science [pdf] by bogomipz on Monday March 06, 2017 @01:27PM (#13804797)
Again I was responding to your comment:

>"The justift for its price is that the market will bear it."

The market will bear it and the market has no choice to bear it are two different things. I have not "rationalized" anything.

Re:Mathematics for Computer Science [pdf] by dragonwriter on Monday March 06, 2017 @05:33PM (#13806698)
> The market will bear it and the market has no choice to bear it are two different things.

With textbooks, there is a choice: go without (either taking the class anyway or not.)

That your perceived cost from going without is higher than the cost of paying for the book is, arguably a sign that the book is priced correctly for value. You seem to think that the book "ought" to be priced by cost to produce as they would be in a perfectly competitive market, but that's very often not a feature of real markets. The pricing is based on conditions in the market, which is very much a real -- if very much not an ideal -- market.

Re:Mathematics for Computer Science [pdf] by bogomipz on Monday March 06, 2017 @10:21PM (#13808027)
Do you actually believe the things you are writing? No, going without a text book is not actually a viable choice if you want to pass a class is it? Are you just trolling?

>"You seem to think that the book "ought" to be priced by cost to produce as they would be in a perfectly competitive market"

Nowhere did I articulate that sentiment at all. There is plenty of room to make a tidy profit without resorting to punitive pricing, even in a captive market.