News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Design Better Data Tables by rocqua on Monday March 06, 2017 @07:25AM (#13802225)
I disagree strongly with only mentioning the units in the first row.

If all units in a column are the same, mention that unit in the column header. Otherwise, you need to mention it everywhere. Only putting units in the first row suggests that the first row is different. It is basically lying in all the other rows, presuming the reader catches the error and understands what is meant.

I also think disagree slightly on color. Restricted use of color makes sense For example red for negative values, or green for highlighted values that you want to stand out.

Heck, if you have very geometric 2-D data, perhaps there is even a point to be made to color the background according to the value so you can 'see' the structure. This is pretty niche though.

Re:Design Better Data Tables by IanCal on Monday March 06, 2017 @07:58AM (#13802346)
> I also think disagree slightly on color. Restricted use of color makes sense For example red for negative values, or green for highlighted values that you want to stand out.

I would argue that while you can use colour to help your documents should be

* Perfectly readable when monochromatic

* Fully understandable without the colour

I would be concerned if you need to add colour for your data to be understood, and if you add it then it should be done with the understanding that not all of your readers will be able to see the same differences as you can (and you might be causing issues by altering things like contrast).

My only other main comment on this is similar, I want the communicated information to not rely on anything visual in tables. Bolding some results to indicate that they're significant is fine, if that information is available in another way, as I hate converting a format and losing information.

Re:Design Better Data Tables by erelde on Monday March 06, 2017 @07:51AM (#13802325)
On color, I like to highlight slightly the row, or column depending on the data, I'm looking at by changing slightly the contrast.
Re:Design Better Data Tables by ilikescience on Monday March 06, 2017 @04:57PM (#13806410)
author here! i think putting the unit in the header also works just fine. it's the same "ink" either way, so it comes down to particular usage.

color-wise, one of the strongest reasons to not use color is the exact situation you mentioned; in some countries (namely, china), green values are negative and red are positive.