News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Get JIRA for $10 only by kelnos on Wednesday May 26, 2010 @07:11AM (#1380015)
Ugh. Pass. We use it at work. It's a very frustrating piece of software. I'd actually prefer to use Bugzilla, for all its warts. Jira's interface is a pain to use. Changing anything about the bug involves loading a new page, and then saving to get back to the original page. Even worse, the edit page has a completely different layout from the view page, so you have to figure out where everything is twice.

Conflict resolution is nonexistent:

1. Users A and B click to edit a bug at the same time. 2. User A changes the assignee and clicks save. 3. User B changes the priority and clicks save. 4. User A refreshes the bug page to find that his assignee change has been reverted.

This is pretty basic, people.

The regular search page is a little odd. If you have multiple 'projects', and click on one to filter by project, a little DHTML bit pops out that asks you to reload the page to make sure all the other fields are up to date. Ajax, anyone?

The hierarchy is a bit overdone: Projects, then Components, then Component Modules, then Component Sub Modules. And you can't set default assignees for CMs or CSMs, so they're really pretty useless, aside from wasting people's time trying to figure out another level of granularity as to where to file the bug. To be fair, they're optional, but...

On the plus side, I really like the advanced search query language: basically just a bunch of boolean and comparison operators, with decent autocomplete functionality. Quite powerful, and not at all hard to use.

Re:Get JIRA for $10 only by shuron on Thursday May 27, 2010 @05:39AM (#1383148)
I'm with you by liking bugzilla. It's also my favorite after JIRA. But JIRA better for people with few IT background. Sometimes we do organize project of non IT context or involve people which are not familiar with IT and tracking systems. That people liked JIRA more than bugzilla.