If it did, companies like Lockmart and SAIC and Northrup-Grumman wouldn't be able to continue winning contracts.
Fast forward to the last couple of months, and you'll find that a lot of Requests for Proposals (RFPs) that are normally issued around this time by various federal agencies haven't been issued: http://blog.seliger.com/2010/02/28/where-have-all-the-rfps-g... . Presumably, the problem is that those agencies are still digesting stimulus-related funds, which in turn is making them less able to do the stuff they're regularly supposed to be doing.
Unfortunately, there doesn't appear to be a lot that can be done. If you have very few regulations or guidance, you'll get people inflating bids and embezzling the old-fashioned way. If you make the process sufficiently arduous, you have companies whose job it is to game the system and who end up taking a cut of whatever the contract is and then pass it down. One way or another, you'll get posts like the parent's and newspaper articles that describe some form or another of corruption.
There ended up a situation where a club could only want 2 to 4 and ended up with about 20 hot water units which they couldn't afford to actually use due to energy costs.
There is the potential for direct kickbacks from builder to principal, but that's relatively unlikely for various reasons.
Of course, there are multiple contractors bidding. But they all know that the bid will be issued, and they know that they all know. With that knowledge, even absent real collusion, you can expect them to act accordingly.
Pile on top of this the regulations dictating that it must be done with union labor at the prevailing wage; that ceilings must be of a given height and doorways recessed; etc. ad nauseam. This prevents the contractor from "thinking outside the box" to streamline the process with good ideas or better leverage their own skills.
So we've got contractors that are hamstrung as to their approach to the project, but otherwise having the upper hand in negotiation. What do you expect to happen?
I thought the suggestion was that we hand a million dollars to the principal of each school and say "here, spend this on building and renovation". (Within certain limits, of course, and with some degree of oversight, to stop 'em from doing anything truly stupid.)
Pile on top of this the regulations dictating that it must be done with union labor at the prevailing wage; that ceilings must be of a given height and doorways recessed; etc. ad nauseam. This prevents the contractor from "thinking outside the box" to streamline the process with good ideas or better leverage their own skills.
afaik it would currently be totally illegal in Australia for the government to dictate that any labour had to be done by union members. The last government did a pretty good job of limiting union power and I don't think the new mob have managed to regress that far yet.
The new government has actually reversed the laws back about 20 years and dismantled many of the anti-union safeguards, largely as a payback to the unions who funded the bulk of the advertising for the last election campaign. As a result, industrial action has increased by a large amount, and we're back to things like christmas strikes by postal workers and baggage handlers, and increasing amounts of violence in the construction industry.
In this case, because the school construction all went to large construction companies, who all have unionised labour, it's a backhanded way of ensuring unionised labour does much of the work, though probably only in metropolitan areas. The rural construction is mostly sub-contracted out to local tradesmen.
In this case, the principals couldnt' even say what they wanted. You were given what you got : a new canteen even if you needed another 3 classrooms. The principals and school parent committees were given very little input into the process.
With that sort of money shovelled quickly out the door, it didn't take long for reporting of corruption and rorts to show up: In some documented cases, the construction costs of simple school buildings mushroomed from $78,000 for a pre-BER quote to an actual built cost of $954,000. All this for a simple school structure. Most of the fat is in 'consulting fees' and 'variations' specified by the builders.
There are many documented cases of school buildings costing in excess of $5400 per square metre - about what it costs to build a top grade office block, and about 3 times what the cost would be normally.
The main problem, it would seem, is that all the contracts go to large building companies, who then subcontract to smaller builders, who then subcontract out to local people. Each person clips the ticket and adds some fat on the way through, and you end up with a building costing 3 times as much. All of this could have been avoided if you just gave the money to the school and got them to hire local tradesmen to do the job, and would have more of an effect on employment and economic activity. As it is, a large percentage of the money will go to shareholders in large construction firms. This is very similar to what the reddit post describes.
The worst thing about the whole thing is, while everyone knows it is happening, and it is in the news, nobody is actually getting into trouble.