News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by superkuh on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:16AM (#13796608)
Unfortunately this will not work. That isn't to say that the construction, placement, and powering of an artificial magnetosphere at Mars-Sun L1 is infeasible. It can totally be done with today's tech and modest meter scale superconducting rings. Mini-Magnetospheric Plasma Propulsion (M2P2): High Speed Propulsion Sailing the Solar Wind (http://earthweb.ess.washington.edu/space/M2P2/STAIF2000.PDF) probably represents the core concept. Except instead of trying to go somewhere you stay where you are. The M2P2 paper says a 10cm diameter superconducting coil can divert solar wind in a bubble up to 20 km in diameter. It wouldn't take too much to scale that up.

Of course diverting that much solar wind would create a force on the object. In the paper above that force is used to accelerate a craft. It'd be some handful of newtons at 20 km and linearly more to do what this project wants. One way you might get around that is to "lean into" the wind by going down the sun-side of the L1 halo orbit and allowing the force from the diverted solar wind to counter the sun's gravity's acceleration.

But for the vast majority of the lost Mar's atmosphere the kinetic energy needed to achieve escape velocity is not from impact with solar wind ions or other solar wind related/magnetic field means. All those hereafter referenced under the umbrella term "jeans escape".

Instead the majority of the kinetic energy needed comes from the ejected electrons from the sun's light ionizing the upper atmosphere. That ejected electron has quite a bit and it is distributed to the ions it later interacts with and as those ions interact with others. If there was no solar wind at all the rate of atmospheric loss at Mars would drop but not significantly if the sun still shone upon it.

That isn't to say that, having no magnetosphere, Mars (or Venus) does not lose an additional small amount of it's atmosphere to jeans escape mechanisms. But that amount is limited due to the currents created in the upper atmosphere by photoionization creating their own local magnetic field. That creates a bow shock about the ionopause which slows the incoming solar wind down such that it's constituent ions no longer have the energy needed to deliver the boost required for escape. And because of the induced magnetic field other solar wind magnetic field based mechanisms which would pick-up the ions ionized by the sun's light are mitigated.

I love the idea of this but it isn't going to make Mars have a decent atmospheric pressure in just some years.

On a (much) lighter note, I was thinking if you put these artificial magnetospheres all over the inner system and then coordinated turning them on and off you could "paint" the termination shock surface of the heliosphere with different scales of tubulence in charge density. It'd be a multi-hundred AU wide screen visible only from very far away with sensitive polarimeters (detecting the changes in lines of sight charge density through faraday rotation). Might be a decent way to METI since it'd not require much energy or high angular resolution at the other end.

tldr: It's technically and economically feasible. But it doesn't work like suggested for atmospheric protection because almost all the mass loss is from light caused photoionization, not the solar wind (and other Jeans escape mechanisms).

Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by bkanber on Monday March 06, 2017 @12:02AM (#13800801)
> But for the vast majority of the lost Mar's atmosphere the kinetic energy needed to achieve escape velocity is not from impact with solar wind ions or other solar wind related/magnetic field means.

Source? That's in direct contradiction with the article stating:

> In addition to determining that solar wind was responsible for depleting Mars' atmosphere, these probes have also been measuring the rate at which it is still being lost today.

You seem to be forgetting that Mars has a very thin atmosphere, so there is no appreciable bow shock created. The upper atmosphere will protect itself only if it's dense enough to create sufficiently strong eddies to deal with peak solar wind. Mars' atmosphere is not dense enough. Venus' is, maybe that's what you're thinking of? Adding a synthetic magnetosphere to Venus will not accomplish much due to the effect you're describing.

And besides, do you really think the Director of Planetary Science of NASA, who recently launched MAVEN to study exactly this topic, somehow missed the core assumption of this project?

You're making a very strong claim, so please provide strong proof of the following:

- Show that "But for the vast majority of the lost Mar's atmosphere the kinetic energy needed to achieve escape velocity is not from impact with solar wind ions or other solar wind related/magnetic field means" -- NASA seems to disagree

- Show that photoionization accounts for "the majority of kinetic energy needed"

- Show that bow shock in Mars' thin atmosphere is sufficiently strong to deflect peak solar wind activity

I don't believe any of those three points are provable for Mars. I believe you can show that bow shock is sufficiently strong on Earth and Venus, but not Mars. I believe you can show that Jeans escape is small on Venus because of the composition of the atmosphere, but not Mars.

Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by pault on Sunday March 05, 2017 @12:42PM (#13797195)
> Might be a decent way to METI since it'd not require much energy or high angular resolution at the other end.

I really don't think this is a good idea, unless we want a massive object accelerated to a significant percentage of c to get lobbed our way. :)

Disregarding the effects on atmosphere loss, wouldn't a machine like this eventually be more or less essential if humans ever decide to move in long term? At least, if we want to hang out on the surface (in bubbles, of course).

Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by VLM on Sunday March 05, 2017 @03:39PM (#13798454)
The good news is "to get lobbed our way" doesn't mean much to a culture that can do distributed projects all over a solar system. A problem along the lines of whats the ideal cannonball size to genocide the common mosquito?

There is also a really nice MAD effect where the window where you can hit a solar system without getting hit back is extremely short, like a century perhaps. Longer than that and we send a probe to the cannonball and turn it into diffuse gray goo that the solar wind blows away when it enters the system, and we return fire 1000 times over, so any logical civilization would send in the asteroid weapons much earlier, like the first time they sniff RF transmissions or the first dark side of the planet electric lights.

Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by mirimir on Monday March 06, 2017 @12:10AM (#13800826)
Well, the attackers in The Killing Star, by Charles R. Pellegrino and George Zebrowski, did more than just lob an object our way. And there's the issue: "One of the iron rules of relativistic bombardment was that if you could see something approaching at 92 percent of light speed, it was never where you saw it when you saw it, but was practically upon you...". So sending probes is rather unworkable.

In the The Killing Star, our doom was already sealed by "Star Trek" :(

Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by thatcherc on Sunday March 05, 2017 @01:04PM (#13797353)
Sounds like something straight out of Cixin Liu's "The Dark Forest"
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by pault on Sunday March 05, 2017 @01:15PM (#13797443)
Indeed, it's a pretty strong argument that the most prudent (in the context of the continuing survival of your own civilization) reaction to discovering a developing civilization in another solar system is to preemptively destroy it. Also, The Algebraist by Iain M. Banks. :)
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by jcoffland on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:00PM (#13797793)
Unless you assume that cooperation is more likely than conflict. Maybe conflict is more common than usual on Earth. Imagine for example a group of worlds that were able to survive only due to cooperation. On encountering us they would likely lean towards cooperation as that was their experience. We might lean towards conflict but our experience tells us little about the average experience of other inhabitants of our galaxy.
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by vidarh on Sunday March 05, 2017 @03:42PM (#13798471)
The scary thing about the xenophobic solution to the Fermi paradox is that there might be lots of nice civiliations around that do want to cooperate - but it could potentially only take a few very aggressive, advanced xenophobic bullies lobbing large objects at anyone they spot before the threshold for everyone else to stay in their metaphorical foxholes hiding until/unless they have very good reason to assume they have established a clear advantage.
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by WillPostForFood on Sunday March 05, 2017 @03:39PM (#13798456)
While we only have a sample of 1 (Earth), we have do millions of samples of interspecies behavior that lean strongly to conflict, and often the cooperation isn't necessarily pleasant for one species either.
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by pault on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:15PM (#13797895)
What if the first message you receive is from a peaceful and advanced civilization, and you reply with "Hi, we are earth, send your teleportation devices here please", and within the 60 years that the round trip message has taken to be received, a military junta has taken over the civilization and decided to exterminate all humans because our exponentially accelerating technology will make us a threat to their hegemony in another 60 years? :)
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by mirimir on Monday March 06, 2017 @12:11AM (#13800831)
I enjoyed that trilogy greatly, but damn, it was depressing :(
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by lutusp on Monday March 06, 2017 @03:22AM (#13801436)
> Disregarding the effects on atmosphere loss, wouldn't a machine like this eventually be more or less essential if humans ever decide to move in long term?

I think it's more practical in the long term to create a magnetic field at Mars itself. Using future technology on a scale unimaginable at present (and similar to that proposed in the linked article), we could magnetize Mars' (now-solid) ferrous materials by the onetime application of a very strong magnetic field.

Mars once had a dynamic magnetic field like ours, but Mars' liquid ferrous materials solidified as the planet cooled, which caused its field to disappear. A permanent field could be created by the deliberate application of a strong temporary field that would magnetize the planet's ferrous materials.

Details: http://arachnoid.com/restoring_mars/

Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by jessaustin on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:58AM (#13796898)
It'd be a multi-hundred AU wide screen visible only from very far away with sensitive polarimeters.

ISTR the Swordholder did something similar in Death's End. The purpose wasn't "light", however.

Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by superkuh on Sunday March 05, 2017 @12:40PM (#13797185)
Yeah, I just think the concept is intrinsically cool which may be a bit of a http://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2011-08-08 issue.

Taking it even further (and more absurd) the interface between the heliosphere and the interstellar medium (ISM) lets in matter mostly along a curved path at the bow who's size and orientation is defined by the relative magnetic vector orientations of the heliosphere and the ISM. This was a recent discovery by the IBEX interstellar neutral atom monitor. If you could get the artificial magnetospheres to influence the magnetic field around the region in the bow where this happens (by controlling the magnetic field in the plasmoids your artificial magnetospheres sends off with the wind) you might be able to control the direction interstellar neutral atoms come in at. And that'd allow you to apply arbitrary (small) force to the entire heliosphere and control direction over very long time periods. But that's so back of the napkin I doubt it's actually feasible.

Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by thatcherc on Sunday March 05, 2017 @01:07PM (#13797379)
I think you're thinking of Project Snowflake which was featured more heavily in The Dark Forest. Awesome trilogy!
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by jessaustin on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:56PM (#13798169)
Of course you're right. It was this project that justified his "promotion" from Wallfacer to Swordholder.
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere by adekok on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:55PM (#13798163)
> Instead the majority of the kinetic energy needed comes from the ejected electrons from the sun's light ionizing the upper atmosphere.

IIRC, at martian surface temperature, hydrogen atoms have escape velocity. That goes a long way to explaining why there's no water on Mars: there's lots of Oxygen, but most of the hydrogen has fled.