It's a survey, and the link text is a quote of one of the surveyors which I only found by clicking view comments then ctrl-f'ing 'immort' which took me far down the list to find this:
Shane Magrath, 48, from Australia, has loved math since grades 9-12
“One day the universe will be a cold black emptiness. However that which is mathematically true will remain vibrantly true even if the universe fades to darkness. When we do mathematics we touch immortality.”
You rely too much on proof by assertion to support your ideology
> does not constitute a proof of existence of anything infinite outside one's mind.
You argue a lack of rigor but refuse to uphold your dismissal to your own projected standards
You even claim there are texts to support your position but choose to leave out a link for others to review
I am comfortably an opposing opinion to your opinion but one of the things that confuses me about those that share it with you is the 'outside the mind' element
Can you elaborate on how mathematical phenomena only exist inside the mind and if so how that proves mathematics fails to exist immortally
Computation is a finitary process, but its behavior is informed by infinity. Even if infinity doesn't "exist" in the sense that we could ever observe and comprehend it, we can see its shadow everywhere.
> The ability to notice some inherent patterns of natural phenomena, such as the ratio of a circle's circumference to its diameter, does yield this ratio to be immortal, or any other inferred constant.
I have to disagree. The fact that there are patterns to notice is a deep mystery of the world and prefigures mathematical truth. Things are different in some ways but the same in other ways. Trivial, but fundamental. The fact that we can find mathematics everywhere relies on this fact.
What is a deep mystery for me, is that life, it seems, does not have the notion of counting at all, at least on the level of cell biology. It is uses "pure functional" molecular structures as "code and data" and message-passing as its "language", but this is quite another topic.
This, BTW, is a hint to justify the principle that what cannot exist without an observer does not exist in principle. There is, obviously the notion of a distance, but not necessarily of space. There is notion of a process as a result of applied forces, but not necessarily of duration and time. Time is a derivative. Derivatives does not exist, physical phenomena do.
Nothing does not depend on the real world, to begin with. Especially, products of the mind conditioned by senses and a language.
The ability to produce an infinite series of numbers (by adding another one) does not constitute a proof of existence of anything infinite outside one's mind.
Good philosophers, like Leibniz and the Indian tradition, which includes early Buddhists, have postulated this, but popular memes are much stronger.
The ability to notice some inherent patterns of natural phenomena, such as the ratio of a circle's circumference to its diameter, does yield this ratio to be immortal, or any other inferred constant.
Math does not exist outside people's minds (contrary to the popular discourse from the Zen And Art Of Motorcycle Maintenance). Only a few of what we call conservative forces and different forms of what we call energy (or matter if you like) which are different aspects of the same That, to which human categories are inapplicable.