I think these tests are a great tool, but like anything we all just need to be aware and careful of the biases introduced. Also, we need to be mindful that really good developers who are employed, have families etc, may not have an over abundance of time to spend on these, so if 10 companies each send a challenge that takes 4 hours, and it's unclear if the assessment will lead to further interviews, some better candidates may give up on the process or be selective about the ones they complete.
I think this creates an additional bias, that the people who complete your assessments may be the ones with the most time to invest in the process (ie the currently unemployed).
The catch? There is no internet in Cuba, so they had to do it using a book, and asking questions to a programmer who was helping them there.
I absolutely would not hire someone who failed that test. Your defence of it seems bizarre to me.