Re:What happens when you swipe a credit card
by digler999 on Saturday March 04, 2017 @04:50PM
(#13793102)
> but the check digit algorithm would have to change
or just get rid of it. It was a relic from 20+ years ago when networks and computers were 1/100th the speed they are today. Let them enter invalid numbers. Let the server return an error (as it already does)
Re:What happens when you swipe a credit card
by rlucas on Saturday March 04, 2017 @08:14PM
(#13794019)
Similarly, once we did away with legacy electromechanical phone switches, the (phone area code) NANPA started allowing area codes with non-[0,1] middle digits. The big form of 10-digit numbers was retained and extended by relaxing a legacy constraint.
That would break so much as most of the message formats and batch files use fixed width fields. It's probably the same for the databases underneath. Changing to alphanumerics sounds nice but the check digit algorithm would have to change from Luhn to Luhn mod n. More breaking changes.
Banking systems are one of the ultimate forms of legacy, which is why most of the security additions have been bolted on. Just look at 3D secure - they added an entire subsection to the message format and it was still just another single factor auth method that nobody wanted and everybody hated.