For instance, this article has someone stating they believe the Bay Area isn't permitting nearly enough housing:
http://www.sfchronicle.com/business/networth/article/Bay-Are...
So the wealthy move into the new housing and are replaced in the old housing by the slightly less wealthy rather than anyone reasonably described as poorer.
This doesn't make sense. They are poorer than the wealthy.
There is still no justification why increasing supply leads to increased costs.
The word used was "poorer". The one with lower income is "poorer"
Virtually anybody who lives in the United States cannot be described as "poorer" by your definition, as we're almost all richer than 95% of the world's population.
It's a great word choice - you're just arguing your personal preferences and vauge implications right now. People are poorer than other people, other than Bill Gates. Since we're talking about housing prices in inflated markets right now, there's a huge difference between an engineer making 160k a year vs a director making 400k a year. The engineer is "poorer".
> it's a poor word choice.
Don't you mean it's a less wealthy word choice, since it's in the top decile of words that are appropriate to use in that situation?
If there was a nice new apartment available, you might rent it. But if there wasn't, you would have to settle for an older apartment, which puts you into direct competition with poorer people over housing stock.
This is what is happening in San Francisco now -- high-income people are bidding up the prices of older apartments, many of which are pretty crappy, because the supply of new apartments is pretty small. This is how the city ended up with 70-year-old crappy apartments renting for more than $3000 per month.
If San Francisco built lots of new luxury apartments, the rich newcomers would live in them, and leave the older apartments available for the people who can't afford to pay more.