Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax...
by lukasm on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:45PM
(#13770672)
What are the good arguments agains revenue tax? Say 1,5%
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax...
by slavik81 on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:10PM
(#13771093)
It makes small businesses even less competitive against large companies. Consider a few businesses. One owns an oil well. One owns a refinery. One owns a gas station.
The oil well sells 100L of crude oil to the refinery for $100 and pays $1.5 in tax. The refinery sells 100L of gasoline to the gas station for $200 and pays $3 in tax. The gas station sells 100L of gasoline to the consumer for $300 and pays $4.5 in tax. Total: $9 in tax.
BigCo owns an oil well, oil refinery and gas station. The only time money changes hands is when they sell 100L of gasoline to the consumer for $300 and pay $4.5 in tax.
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax...
by milcron on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @09:19PM
(#13770861)
Isn't that just a sales tax shuffled around?
One person's revenue is another person's purchase.
Re:Border-adjusted cash flow tax (to replace corporation tax...
by gydfi on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @09:21PM
(#13770873)
Huge transfer of wealth from low-margin businesses to high-margin businesses.
Supermarkets, for instance, have margins of about 3%. With a revenue tax they'd be completely boned. They could raise their prices, of course. But the bigger supermarket chains would be better off buying out their own supply chain.