Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by MrZongle2 on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:33PM
(#13768630)
Which is why gun-free zones are the safest places. /s
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by pikzen on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:42PM
(#13768713)
A simple look at other countries would tend to say that, yes.
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by Zak on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:04PM
(#13770015)
Were that true, we would expect Switzerland (3rd highest number of guns per capita in the world) to have a higher murder rate than the UK (82nd in guns per capita), but it does not. This lack of correlation continues with other European countries: Serbia and Sweden have a fair number of guns, but not much murder, while Ukraine and Lithuania have few guns, but some of the highest murder rates in Europe.
If you're about to point out that social, economic and political conditions are very different in Switzerland and Ukraine, you're probably on to something. Murder rates of various countries do correlate with several measures of social, economic and political stability, but not with gun ownership.
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by richardwhiuk on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:04PM
(#13770438)
Switzerland has guns, but no bullets. So you can probably give up guns or bullets and get gun safety - not that that's a very startling conclusion.
Secondly the fact that A=>B doesn't mean that also C=>B so you should expect high B when either A or C is true.
(Read => as implies, causes or correlates with - it doesn't really matter).
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by Zak on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:23PM
(#13770564)
That isn't true. You're probably thinking of the change to ammunition issued by the army to members of the militia (a large fraction of the population) for civil defense. It is no longer standard practice to issue ammunition to keep at home.
Buying ammunition from a gun store appears to be an option for anyone with any of several types of gun license.
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by benjohnson on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @04:59PM
(#13768882)
It really depends on the sample - if you look over the last 100 years the picture really changes. You'll find massive government killings of their own unarmed citizens.
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by daenney on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @05:59PM
(#13769459)
Yet would those massive government killings of their own citizens not have happened if those citizens had guns? There are plenty of methods a government can use to kill large swaths of its population without ever coming in contact with said population, even a 100 years ago.
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by JBReefer on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:30PM
(#13770598)
The strongest military on Earth couldn't defeat a bunch of illiterate people with 40 year old guns in terrain they knew well.
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by 15155 on Thursday March 02, 2017 @11:38AM
(#13775446)
Anti-firearms people love to imply that weapons of mass destruction and other exotic shit would be used to quell uprisings in an American Revolution-style event.
"You can't stop planes and tanks with a rifle, therefore the Second Amendment is useless!"
Small arms seemed to work just fine in Vietnam and Afghanistan.
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by kbenson on Thursday March 02, 2017 @12:15PM
(#13775888)
Personally, I think it would be more useful to ban (or make harder to get) handguns than automatic weapons. In almost all the legitimate uses of guns I can think of, rifles and shotguns work just fine. Easily concealed firearms are the problem. Make those more problematic to own and buy.
Re:Leaked Snapchat emails: Anti-gun group told to pay or NRA...
by daenney on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:58PM
(#13771290)
So we'll just forget about (atomic) bombs that we drop from the sky, gasses and other biological agents, cutting them off from necessary resources like water (or poisoning it) and food and so on? The strongest military in the world could probably just outlast them. Might take another 100 years though.