Re:ReBreakCaptcha: Breaking Google’s ReCaptcha v2 Using Google
by problems on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @12:42PM
(#13766125)
Yeah, it's really brutal. I find the new recaptchas which I hit almost every time are much more exhausting than the old text-based ones, and probably much easier for a machine to solve to boot.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:ReBreakCaptcha: Breaking Google’s ReCaptcha v2 Using Google
by zodPod on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @03:07PM
(#13767758)
The worst are the questions like "Click the images with a store front" what the hell is a store front? Especially in today's world.. Is a garage a store front? Is a hot dog stand a store front? Same with like "Click the images with cars" but there's a crossover. Is that a car? Is a station wagon a car?
Re:ReBreakCaptcha: Breaking Google’s ReCaptcha v2 Using Google
by Ajedi32 on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @03:28PM
(#13767989)
I've found it's best to just not think about it too much. CAPTCHAs are, after all, designed to "tell Computers and Humans Apart". You're a human, so just pick whatever seems reasonable and move on. If the system doesn't accept your answer, that's _its_ fault, not yours.
Re:ReBreakCaptcha: Breaking Google’s ReCaptcha v2 Using Google
by probably_wrong on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @05:12PM
(#13769022)
I've gotten several times the one asking for "tea", that requires you to select three pictures of coffee[1]. With the store fronts, at least I can read what they say. They are often in Spanish, for one reason.
Re:ReBreakCaptcha: Breaking Google’s ReCaptcha v2 Using Google
by problems on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @03:16PM
(#13767863)
Yeah, I think this is a big reason it feels like I'm spending a lot more mental energy to solve these captchas than the old ones.
Re:ReBreakCaptcha: Breaking Google’s ReCaptcha v2 Using Google
by H4CK3RM4N on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:04PM
(#13770020)
These are almost certainly just Google training its car AI.
Re:ReBreakCaptcha: Breaking Google’s ReCaptcha v2 Using Google
by frogpelt on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @01:22PM
(#13766608)
"probably much easier for a machine to solve to[sic]"
Surely, CAPTCHA wasn't replaced with something less dificult for machines to solve.
Have you seen research to indicate this?
Re:ReBreakCaptcha: Breaking Google’s ReCaptcha v2 Using Google
by cbhl on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @02:39PM
(#13767463)
The state of the art has improved so much that for the older tasks, computers are arguably better than humans at them:
https://arxiv.org/abs/1312.6082
So humans have to clear higher and higher hurdles to prove themselves human while the computers use the answers from the captchas to get closer to humans' capabilities.
Re:ReBreakCaptcha: Breaking Google’s ReCaptcha v2 Using Google
by problems on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @01:53PM
(#13766942)
I was meaning to use the idiom "to boot", you cut off a word.
Perhaps my grammar wasn't correct there though.
In any case, check out the blackhat presentation about using Google's image recognition to solve the image based captchas. There are a wide variety of fairly advanced image recognition tools but a surprisingly small number of complex text recognition ones.
Re:ReBreakCaptcha: Breaking Google’s ReCaptcha v2 Using Google
by inafewwords on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @01:48PM
(#13766886)
Someone will train a pigeon to break captchas some day just for fun. In reference to pigeons being trained to diagnose cancer in X-rays.