[1] http://seekingalpha.com/article/4049862-investment-advice-wa...
A reasonably chosen self-selected buy-and-hold portfolio will, on average, perform just about as well as an index fund. Psychologically it can be better or worse depending on your personality because you get/have to take responsibility for your profit/loss.
I think the goal of an index fund is to normalize results, so that you don't happen to be the guy who ends up significantly below average.
Let's say I want to take an Alaskan cruise, but I don't quite have the money. If I get a higher return I'll have enough to go. If I get a lower return I won't go, and I'll still have enough money for rent. In my (admittedly contrived) scenario I'm willing to accept more risk as long as my returns are potentially higher.
Self-selecting a bunch of stocks increases your risk profile compared to using an index fund of the whole stock market, but you incur significantly more trading costs as a result. If you want to increase your possible returns at greater risks, there are cheaper ways of doing it.
This really goes to show, however, how the everyday man has no hope, as an investor, against the big boys.
Edit: I origionally wanted to link to this startup https://spaceknow.com/ but couldn't remember the name.