News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As France’s Towns Wither, Fears of a Decline in ‘Frenchness’ by VLM on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @05:36PM (#13758883)
Yet if you sum the value of property its very unusual for the net worth of a city to exceed the net worth of its metro area suburbs. Lets explore the concept in detail with automobiles.

Most people buy compact commuter cars, lets say. It really doesn't matter what kind of car is the most expensive car, that probably being sports cars. The price of a Ferrari being a large multiple of the price of a Honda Civic means surprisingly very little, or at least it should...

In 2015 about 300K honda civics were sold for lets say $19K each vs 7664 Ferrari sales for $400K each in the USA.

Yes I understand perfectly that the typical Ferrari sells for $400K and a Civic sells for $19K so apparently market clearing prices for Ferrari's dwarfs prices for Civics by a factor of almost exactly 21. Clearly we should socially engineer all our car laws to greatly encourage Ferrari ownership and all our social signalling memes should revolve around the superiority of Ferrari ownership.

However... 300K Honda Civics at 19K is roughly $5.7B in sales. And Ferrari sales of 7664 cars at $400K is almost exactly $3B. Clearly the marketplace has spoken and Ferraris and Civics are roughly equal in the marketplace and should be equal in the world of memes and social signalling.

But wait, there's 300K civic owners and 7664 ferrari owners. Clearly the socially engineered car laws should favor civics, not ferraris.

The world of property is somewhere between the 2nd and 3rd examples. The first example is simply irrelevant.

Cities have some expensive properties and proportionately no one lives there. I'm well aware that culturally its a huge social mistake to pretend anything or anyone matters other than the big cities, regardless how few live there. Most people want the suburb life that we must be convinced to socially engineer laws to destroy.

Re:As France’s Towns Wither, Fears of a Decline in ‘Frenchness’ by Symbiote on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @05:49PM (#13758980)
I don't see how the analogy fits. Are people being forced to buy Ferraris?

Most people would want the Ferrari, or a similarly expensive car in a different style (Rolls Royce, Tesla, whatever). In fact, both. But they can afford neither.

Most people would also like a home in the city centre, or one in a village in the countryside, mountains or on the coast. Or both. Who would choose suburbia? It's a compromise, and in every respect the city centre or the village is better.

Re:As France’s Towns Wither, Fears of a Decline in ‘Frenchness’ by majormajor on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @06:20PM (#13759248)
> Who would choose suburbia? It's a compromise, and in every respect the city centre or the village is better.

Sure, having the only big house with a big yard in a city center would be awesome, but there's a surface area issue where it isn't physically possible to have as many homes in the city centre. So it isn't merely a compromise around cost, it's that there couldn't possibly be enough homes (of the type people enjoy living in in the suburbs) in the city center.

City center living is just as much a compromise: a nice private yard would be great, but I'm giving it up for a more walkable neighborhood. More storage space would be great, but I'm giving it up for a shorter commute. Etc. And if I lived in a city with better traffic, I wouldn't prioritize the commute time as much, so I'd be much more likely to intentionally choose suburbs.

Suburb vs village is a separate question where I would choose suburb 9 times out of 10. You're likely to be in easy distance of far more cultural, entertainment, and dining options.

Re:As France’s Towns Wither, Fears of a Decline in ‘Frenchness’ by VLM on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @06:00PM (#13759071)
Yes I know that last line is the only socially acceptable thing to say. But when the money meets the real estate contract, most people won't live that way unless laws are passed to force them to live that way, to prevent suburbia, to destroy existing suburban areas.

We both agree there is only one politically correct opinion for the only "correct" lifestyle. Pointing out that most people don't like it, don't live it, and will not tolerate laws to annihilate their current lifestyle, is useful in that there's no real point in talking about legally working to destroy the suburbs when so many people like it there as opposed to the very small number in the city.

No matter how many people post on HN about how they love the city and the burbs must be destroyed by any means necessary legal or otherwise, meanwhile ten real estate contracts were signed by people upgrading to the burbs. Obviously whatever strategy is being used for urban boosterism is socially popular yet in a practical business sense is a complete economic failure.

Re:As France’s Towns Wither, Fears of a Decline in ‘Frenchness’ by skewart on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @06:55PM (#13759509)
What are these laws forcing people to live in cities or somehow aimed at destroying suburbia?

In reality, the laws that do exist tend to be aimed at trying to force people to live in suburbia and _not_ a dense city. Lots of municipalities ban density - either out-right or through absurd minimum parking requirements and other design specifications that severely limit what people can build on their land. Plus decades of transportation planning, and current funding decisions, have been aimed at undermining urban neighborhoods in favor of suburban sprawl.

In general, people who advocate for legal reform to facilitate more urban living are saying there should be _less_ regulation and government intervention into how people live and what they do with their land.

Of course some people want to live in suburbia. That's great. No one is trying to stop them. The tens of millions of people who want to live in dense walkable neighborhoods are sick of people trying to stop them.

Re:As France’s Towns Wither, Fears of a Decline in ‘Frenchness’ by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @06:37PM (#13759385)
> most people don't like it, don't live it, and will not tolerate [urban density]

Some don't and won't. But others do. I live in a small apartment in the centre of Manhattan. I measure my commute in minutes, and that only because I choose to detour to the many coffee, tea, bagel, juice and breakfast-ramen-in-a-cup shops nearby. My laundry gets picked and dropped off for free, maintenance is someone else's worry and I have an abundance of city services available to me (for which I pay out the nose for through taxes). Going home to my parents' suburbia is relaxing but not how I'd like to live.

These perks I enjoy--diverse people, foods and cultural experiences nearby--are a function of density. Give us city folk more space and you reduce the number of customers within walking distance of each store, reducing their carrying capacities, thereby changing the fundamental dynamic that gives cosmopolitan life its colour.

This isn't for everyone. But lots of people willingly--aspirationally, even--move to cities. Note that chateau life is costly--many Americans don't see why their taxes should subsidise it. (Particularly when it appears to be low-income Americans paying for richer Americans' suburbs [1].) Democratic debate is how we'll find a balance.

[1] https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/1/9/the-real-reason...

Re:As France’s Towns Wither, Fears of a Decline in ‘Frenchness’ by yarrel on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @06:17PM (#13759222)
You are confusing being unable to pay with desire.

They are very different things.

Re:As France’s Towns Wither, Fears of a Decline in ‘Frenchness’ by Symbiote on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @03:56AM (#13762335)
If you think I'm distorting what I write to appear socially acceptable, the discussion is pointless.