Re:Advanced programming languages
by chc on Monday May 24, 2010 @06:09PM
(#1375816)
To give a concrete example: The printf function in Haskell takes on the responsibilities of both the traditional printf (printing to the screen) and sprintf (generating a formatted string). Haskell knows which it's supposed to do based on whether the return value is used in an IO context or as a string.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Which is, when you think about it, not a good idea. If 'sprintf' is defined, then 'printf' ought to be simply 'putStr . sprintf'.
But sprintf is not defined in Haskell, nor is it really needed. printf returns a typeclass that includes both 'String' and 'IO a'.
My point is that there should be no typeclass; there's no reason to combine IO and formatting in the same function, and doing so makes it more difficult to read and modify code.
Re:Advanced programming languages
by loewenskind on Tuesday May 25, 2010 @04:26AM
(#1376837)
Agreed. This is something I dislike about Haskell. After seeing the regex class and it tons of contexts I was just thinking "didn't they learn anything from perl?".