(The companies with great products on the web – YouTube, Twitter, Google, flickr, Dropbox and so on – in general all don’t have the kinds of professional logos pre-web companies – Mercedes, IBM, Microsoft, Apple and so on – have. Maybe that’s why professional-looking logos don’t manage to inspire much confidence in me on the web.)
Just providing a counterpoint BTW. You may well be right.
> If you google for 'duck search', DDG is the first result.
As ssp pointed out (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1226660) you could hardly find something less conspicuous than a duck face in a big red circle. In my view it's a great asset.
Google is kind of a weird word, but it didn't feel quite as silly even way back when it came out. Same with Bing.
When you visit their site, do you think of rain forests or Xena?
Cartoon ducks aren't quite comparable, IMHO.
Sure Google, Yahoo, Ask Jeeves, Bing all sound fairly weird - but they were also "new" words with no previous connotations to normal people. Even the name Bing got some hate initially but it has mostly gone away now, DDG remains a name that misses with people. Isn't Duck Duck Go a playground game?
Sorry man, I love your site and actually use it as my default search, but the branding blows. I'm actually going to doodle a better brand for you.
I claim that DDG is a name that hits with people. However, it's a name that people think misses with other people. In other words, I think it's a matter of people imputing some overly-starched-shirt attitude onto others.
The Internet is based on the work of extremely silly people, who just happened to be formidable enough to make their iconoclasm the standard.
DuckDuckGo is exactly the kind of silly, eccentric name that reassures me of competence. Never trust a serious man if you want to change the world.
I want a search engine whose design, name, logo, and style inspire me with confidence and reassurance. I want to see power, I want to see professionalism. I don't want to play games with a duck that lucks like it was drawn by an amateur. I think spending a mere 1k on design and branding will have an incredible impact on DDD now that it's really beginning to get off the ground and catch the eye of people outside the HN/Reddit communities.