News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Taking the awkwardness out of a Prenup - A Game Theoretic... by JoeAltmaier on Monday May 24, 2010 @08:04AM (#1374406)
What a strange article. Only a geek could even think such a thing. "Taking the awkwardness out"? To find out your impending spouse had signed a contract that bound them to create an ironclad prenup with you, would mark you as the most suspicious, manipulative bastard on earth. That relieves the awkwardness of finding out later I suppose.
Re:Taking the awkwardness out of a Prenup - A Game Theoretic... by jjs on Monday May 24, 2010 @10:19AM (#1374682)
To find out your impending spouse had signed a contract that bound them to create an ironclad prenup with you, would mark you as the most suspicious, manipulative bastard on earth.

"On the contrary, my dear. Look at Section 4, Paragraph 3:

We can be entirely free of this contract if I donate all my worldly possessions to charity!"

Re:Taking the awkwardness out of a Prenup - A Game Theoretic... by yummyfajitas on Monday May 24, 2010 @08:38AM (#1374489)
How is it manipulative? It is nothing more than binding one's future self to a certain behavior.

By that same logic it is manipulative of the spouse to attempt to bind your future self to other behavior (only doing it with her, sharing property, etc).

Re:Taking the awkwardness out of a Prenup - A Game Theoretic... by JoeAltmaier on Monday May 24, 2010 @02:07PM (#1375276)
You preempt your spouse from any part in the discussion. A spouse is different from a business partner, in that they are supposed to be party to important decisions.
Re:Taking the awkwardness out of a Prenup - A Game Theoretic... by yummyfajitas on Monday May 24, 2010 @03:57PM (#1375534)
Most people do that on all sorts of non-prenup topics (e.g., sex with third parties, children). What makes a prenup special?
Re:Taking the awkwardness out of a Prenup - A Game Theoretic... by JoeAltmaier on Monday May 24, 2010 @04:35PM (#1375623)
What? Sign a contract with a 3rd party to avoid any chance of discussion? Really?
Re:Taking the awkwardness out of a Prenup - A Game Theoretic... by yummyfajitas on Monday May 24, 2010 @07:25PM (#1375948)
Plenty of people preempt any discussion of certain topics and offer their spouse a "take it or leave it" choice.

The most common mechanism of doing this is a credible claim of future emotional reactions ("I wouldn't feel the same way about you if you have sex with other people"), or perhaps the reactions of third parties ("my mom would disown me if I married a non-Lutheran"). I don't see what makes this mechanism so unique.

Re:Taking the awkwardness out of a Prenup - A Game Theoretic... by JoeAltmaier on Monday May 24, 2010 @09:35PM (#1376184)
Yes of course. But to do it with an elaborate plan, set in motion ahead of time and sprung on them unexpected, is a species of cold, reptilian logic that defies rationalization.
Re:Taking the awkwardness out of a Prenup - A Game Theoretic... by lionhearted on Monday May 24, 2010 @08:45AM (#1374501)
> To find out your impending spouse had signed a contract that bound them to create an ironclad prenup with you, would mark you as the most suspicious, manipulative bastard on earth.

Well, at least, unromantic and pragmatic. Me, I do work in business and science and I think it'd be irresponsible to potentially allow 50% control of my research, writings, and businesses I found/work in/develop/etc to go to someone else. Anyone that comes on to work for me needs to know that there's no chance that half my ownership share passes to someone else in the future, or that I need to take on debt or promises of a certain cash payment to retain the share.

For real life examples, look at how divorce wrecked the San Diego Padres baseball franchise - and the Moores had been married 45 years!

Community property? That's fine if no one stands to lose besides you, but I feel like it'd be personally pretty irresponsible of me to enter into a situation where divorce could ruin not just my business and life, but my staff, suppliers, clients, and people who count on me. Some people might say, "But if you have a great marriage and pick the right woman it wouldn't happen!" To that I say,

1. Everyone thinks that way and quite a few of them turn out to be mistaken.

2. I don't think my judgment is infallible, and I refuse to put other people's lives and livelihood unnecessarily at risk.

I agree it's still potentially awkward though - you need good communication about expectations early on.

Re:Taking the awkwardness out of a Prenup - A Game Theoretic... by JoeAltmaier on Monday May 24, 2010 @01:45PM (#1375197)
The prenup - fine. The tortuous logic that brings you to creating a 2nd contract, solely to relieve you of the burden of communicating meaningfully with your potential spouse - there's where it crosses the line.