Determining "stuff" on car ownership may be misleading.
Examples. Mercedes acquired by co worker. He said family was so poor he had to wear his big brothers clothes.
Another person I am working with now used to live out of his car. Within his 2nd paycheck he leased a new BMW.
Cars were used to "feel good" and perhaps elevate class self perception.
Basically, replacing all demographic data that the census brings with the single factor of car ownership. In the region where the actual correlation is less than 90%, the data generated is completely useless.
That is not what I read. They wrote, "complement," and never suggested replacing.
Ah, I missed that, sorry! To be honest I only skimped through the description, for other lazy people like me here's the relevant line:
> Our results suggest that automated systems for monitoring demographic trends may effectively complement labor-intensive approaches, with the potential to detect trends with fine spatial resolution, in close to real time.
which I also find as a little bit crazy.
Otherwise I find the project quite interesting. I quite like to lose (too much time) on GStreetView, and at the same time I developed an interest in 20-30-40-year old cars, so I wrote a small Chrome extension that allows me to locally save images of old cars that I find on my country's roads while "taking a walk" on GStreetView, along with the relevant info (lat-lng, address, and the make and model of the cars which I input by hand using said extension). I had also noticed that there's a distinct correlation between a city's economic status and the cars you can find on its streets, and I was wondering how hard would it be to do the car "recognition" using some AI-thing and try to draw some conclusions from that. Glad that someone actually did it.
I don't think you missed it. If so, I've missed it after reading the paper twice.
I always answer: that's why I have a lot of money.
So, you don't trust surveys? You don't A/B test your marketing?
Estimates are useful. Hell, your brain is just estimating what's in front of you based on a sample of photons coming in through your eyes. If you trust your vision, you're trusting statistical sampling. I suppose it's possible the USS Enterprise is cloaked and somehow your eyes are deceiving you, but the photons are certainly correlated with what's in front of you.
Some of the best statistical innovations are simply discoveries of good proxies for something that's difficult to measure. Google found that what you search for is a good proxy for what you want to buy. Facebook found that what your friends click on is a good proxy for what you'll click on. Of course you won't like everything Netflix suggests, but its suggestions will (hopefully) be better than just picking movies randomly.
You may use census data to train a neural net to draw some conclusions, not to produce brand new census data.
Why not appreciate the proxy for what it is?
My point is that there is a hype around AI that makes it look that it can do things that it can't. What they do in this paper is equivalent to using a correlation matrix, and a bunch of observations to generate a completely random population that matches what we input in there (ok, the neural net may find some non-linear relationships, but you get the idea). Yes, there is a significant correlation between car ownership and demographics, so the results do look good from far away, but the reality is that they will only map the car ownership factors on to other traits, and in terms of information, it is way poorer than actually doing a census.
I am curious, because at first glance this seems really useful. But trying to see where the limits actually are.
AI-based profiling of anything is bound to filter off outliers. Censuses are made in the field for a reason. The goal is to gather data so that you can make statistical reasoning on it. Not the opposite!!!!
Here, they just gather some car data, and infer demographic data from it. And then what? We've just created a population which matches the car sample. We can't draw ANY conclusion from that data, beyond the type of cars that are found in such and such neighborhoods.