Effectively, what you're saying is "fuzzy" ideas have low value, and we would end up with market for full business plans.
Re:Ideas are not worthless
by whacked_new on Saturday March 15, 2008 @06:52PM
(#137769)
Pretty much, yes. Amusingly, language is "fuzzy" by nature, which is why human-human communication is so verbose. So the word "ideas" has debatable meaning. What you call an idea, I may call a whole business plan, or vice verse, or some other combination of things.
Aside of that, someone indeed has created a "business plan" market website. I don't remember what it's called, but if you can't find it, I can try fishing it out.
A really good idea will include enough details, that it spills over into "execution." It's not just an idea-market. It's an idea-market where people submit via a form that looks like this, click that button, get scored this way. We will launch it by doing this, talking to those people, and focusing on this sector. We will convert this into physical and monetary value by selling this service.
Now, that may be an idea that is worth something.
While you have described certain approaches, until you have a very sharp focus that describes exactly how to get from point A to B (nothing to full product), which means not just "one way to do this is...", but "this is how we will do it," then the idea really is not "executable."