Re:Show HN: Summarise all code annotation like TODO or FIXME
by jacquesm on Sunday February 26, 2017 @05:48PM
(#13740467)
The name on the license was changed I think that totally justifies the remarks made and they were made extremely courteous given the situation.
Forking is fine, merging two packages is fine, removing the authors name from the license (while leaving his name all over the rest of the package, which shows that there is no malicious intent, merely some confusion) is not.
Re:Show HN: Summarise all code annotation like TODO or FIXME
by LeFever on Sunday February 26, 2017 @05:41PM
(#13740444)
Except it isn't a fork. It's basically two projects merged into a new one and a small blurb in the readme to that effect. Why not fork and contact John about taking the original one over? If he doesn't respond within a reasonable time, run with the fork. I don't get the sense that happened here.
I think the issue is less about license and more about what is good form and helps to keep the ecosystem a bit less cluttered.
Then, your choice of words is not ideal:
>NOTE: I no longer actively maintain this package. I'd love to get PRs to keep it going though!
If it's not maintained anymore then I as a developer don't really gain anything (bugfixes, features) by submitting a PR vs. just forking myself. So the choice to fork is understandable, even if it's not what you intended to happen.
[1] https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/10/how-d...