Re:GCC optimized code gives strange floating point results
by thechao on Sunday February 26, 2017 @03:25PM
(#13739623)
Part of my day job is to test floating point hardware and write compilers and assemblers. Testing equality---with some care---is completely fine. I can assure you this is a bug in GCC. The GCC bug is compounded by the nonstandard behavior of x87. The x87 unit is not "fixable" but GCC's behavior is.
Just because someone doesn't know the basics of floating point numbers it doesn't mean that the floating point format is somehow evil.
Testing floats for equality is one of those no-nos which is taught right in the first class of introduction to FP numbers.
Another very basic issue covered right in the intro clsses are problems caused by using decimal values to define numbers encoded in binary format, which is often explained through the famous "0.1 doesn't exist in binary" trivia bit.