News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Surgeons Should Not Look Like Surgeons by libertymcateer on Friday February 24, 2017 @02:18PM (#13726741)
> When you have a highly overvalued attribute, that attribute becomes an indicator of overvaluation.

That is a hell of a leap. It is actually a strict logical fallacy, called affirming the consequent. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirming_the_consequent

In other words this is a huge gap in your reasoning, it is claim - not a conclusion - that you are making and it is one that requires evidence. To put it another way: your argument is wholly conclusory and the only way to settle this argument is with evidence. It cannot be derived from first principle. There may be some instances where surface-level indicia (I can tell about the quality of a fabric pretty quickly, and it is typically indicative of good tailoring) are strongly correlated with quality and others where there is a low (a fresh paint job on a house) or even a potenitally inverse correlation (REALLY NICE ads for attorneys - located on bus stops).

But your blanket statement is just unsupported. I am not saying it is false - I am saying it is unsupported and you are jumping to a huge conclusion that does not follow logically, nor can it be proved to follow on the basis of logic alone.

Re:Surgeons Should Not Look Like Surgeons by travisjungroth on Friday February 24, 2017 @03:05PM (#13727318)
That logical fallacy is not equivalent to what I'm saying.

    Assume attribute X is overvalued.
    Object A has attribute X.
    Object A is indicated to be overvalued.
This may not meet the strict requirements of a college logic class as stated, but I still believe it is true.

I'm not making a statement here about exactly what attributes are overvalued (fabric, paint jobs, bus stops or otherwise).

An argument of the article is that "image" is overvalued. I don't think the author did the best job supporting this argument.

Re:Surgeons Should Not Look Like Surgeons by Domenic_S on Friday February 24, 2017 @04:15PM (#13727966)
The fallacy he's intuiting is really the implied denial of the antecedent:

  If X, then Y
  !X
  Therefore, !Y
As in:

  Attribute X is overvalued
  Object B does NOT have attribute X.
  Therefore Object B is NOT overvalued.
So in other words, your statement may be true:

> When you have a highly overvalued attribute, that attribute becomes an indicator of overvaluation.

but the implication of the inverse: when you DON'T have a highly overvalued attribute, lack of that attribute becomes an indicator of a lack of overvaluation. is not.