Re:Toddlers’ grammar skills not inherent, but learned, new S...
by dilemma on Friday February 24, 2017 @01:13PM
(#13726063)
Children learn language without instruction. That is all. Clearly, there is innate linguistic capability in humans.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Toddlers’ grammar skills not inherent, but learned, new S...
by delinka on Friday February 24, 2017 @02:05PM
(#13726613)
My granddaughter (1y 8m) uses flossers without instruction. Clearly, there is innate tooth hygiene in humans.
No, what's happening is she's mimicking the adults in the house. She's observing and repeating. She's done the same thing with dolls: put them on her shoulder, pat them, make shushing noises ... because we do that with her; because she see's others do that with other babies.
"Instruction"? No. But the only "innate" behaviors this child has involve eating and curiosity. Everything else is spurred by that innate curiosity.
Re:Toddlers’ grammar skills not inherent, but learned, new S...
by ovulator on Friday February 24, 2017 @01:45PM
(#13726393)
Without instruction? They are watching people speak for years. They even have people "teach" it to them. Can you say, "Daddy"? While slowing down and enunciating.
We are unfortunately very aware that when isolated, kids don't learn to speak. So it isn't innate.