News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Android fragmented or is this the new rate of innovation? by ZeroGravitas on Sunday May 23, 2010 @03:40AM (#1371997)
I dunno. One of Apple's big innovations with the iPhone was to take the carriers out the loop when it came to software updates. This remains a big benefit of their plug it into a computer strategy (aka "digital hub").

Google appears to be aiming for the same thing, but OTA and with a more carrot and stick approach. Look here's a shiny new version of Android with new features and better speed. Oh, you can't have it for 6 months because your phone vendor wants to muck around with it to no great purpose, well that's a shame, but don't get suckered next time you upgrade.

You seem to be claiming it's all about hardware (apparently all phones released so far can do 2.1 if updates are available), when it's really all about carrier and phone vendor relationships.

Personally if the maps app gets updated once a week then that strikes me as good for the customer, they shouldn't really have to care.

Re:Is Android fragmented or is this the new rate of innovation? by lenni on Sunday May 23, 2010 @04:52AM (#1372041)
You're saying what I'm thinking. I have a (European) HTC Hero and HTC combined with T-Mobile make the crappiest, most sluggish update experience possible. I am very disappointed with them - so much that will probably buy an iPhone next time around.

Also HTC's Sense UI is a perfect case of what you call "phone vendor wants to muck around with it to no great purpose".

Re:Is Android fragmented or is this the new rate of innovation? by dlib on Sunday May 23, 2010 @05:40AM (#1372072)
I also have a HTC Hero and exactly the same experience. I don't care for the Sense UI and next time I'll get a phone that runs the native Android UI (a Google phone or they should force that any phone with alternative UI's also can run the native UIso upgrades are possible) or an iPhone.

The future looks good for Android but there's still a lot of work to be done.

Re:Is Android fragmented or is this the new rate of innovation? by mechanical_fish on Sunday May 23, 2010 @11:06AM (#1372379)
I agree: Carrier and vendor relationships are the root cause of the problem, not incompatible chips or anything.

Maybe I should have used a different word than hardware, but I'll stand by that word rather than replace it with some airy abstract phrase like total product experience. When I say "Google is now in the hardware business" what I mean is: The average customer buys the physical phone, the OS, the carrier, the contract, and the warranty as part of one big package. Unless the customer is among the 0.0001% of customers who read Make magazine, they don't buy the hardware and software separately, nor -- in the USA -- do they get to independently shop for a carrier. They buy a package, and they call that package a phone. They want the whole package to work and be supported. If the new version of the Maps app doesn't run on their phone, my guess is that this average customer doesn't say gosh, the hardware is compatible, the software could theoretically work, and the open-source maintainers are on my side, but it's too bad about my platform's dysfunctional carrier-vendor relationship. They say "gosh, my phone sucks now".

It's a problem for everyone. In Apple-land it manifests as "the iPhone has terrible reception and doesn't support tethering", though of course the iPhone hardware and software offer pretty good reception and do support tethering; it's AT&T that sucks. In Android-land it manifests as platform fragmentation: There is no one thing called Android; instead there are half a dozen little Androids no two of which are alike.