Re:White House Indicates Potential Crackdown on Recreational...
by AnimalMuppet on Thursday February 23, 2017 @07:09PM
(#13719311)
IANAL. But it might be possible that the Supreme Court no longer regards Wickard as good precedent. IIRC, the Obamacare case got decided in a way that said that the individual mandate could not be justified as "interstate commerce", but that it could be justified as a tax.
This may leave the Feds needing to say, "We can't prohibit it. That's outside the powers given to the Federal government. But we can tax it, and tax it highly enough that nobody can afford it..."
Re:White House Indicates Potential Crackdown on Recreational...
by foo2 on Thursday February 23, 2017 @07:00PM
(#13719232)
United States v. Lopez (1995) hopefully started cutting back on such a laughable decision. Can you think of any behavior which doesn't in some indirect way affect interstate commerce?
If the founding fathers had intended for an unrestricted commerce clause, they wouldn't have bothered with the 10th amendment or enumerating the other powers. The constitution is a whitelist.
Re:White House Indicates Potential Crackdown on Recreational...
by wtbob on Thursday February 23, 2017 @06:52PM
(#13719155)
> It's already been tried and failed with medical marijuana. And, for that matter, commercial wheat farming, in Wickard v. Filburn (1942).
> It's unlikely recreational marijuana would result in a different result.
I dunno, with originalists like Thomas & (hopefully) Gorsuch it's certainly possible. Bad precedent needn't necessarily stand, after all.
Re:White House Indicates Potential Crackdown on Recreational...
by dragonwriter on Thursday February 23, 2017 @07:29PM
(#13719496)
> I dunno, with originalists like Thomas & (hopefully) Gorsuch it's certainly possible.
Compared to Raich (2005), even if Gorsuch flipped from the way Scalia went you need another vote; Thomas was on the Court then so is no change.
It's already been tried and failed with medical marijuana, Gonzales v. Raich (2005). And, for that matter, commercial wheat farming, in Wickard v. Filburn (1942).
It's unlikely recreational marijuana would result in a different result.