Re:Harvey Friedman bringing incompleteness and infinity out ...
by pron on Thursday February 23, 2017 @05:20PM
(#13718376)
> A lot of mathematics is inspired by physical considerations, but mathematical concepts are themselves not physical.
I'm not sure I understand your point. It is true that any computation can be modeled mathematically, but so can any other physical process. Also, computation does not require a specific physical implementation and is an abstract concept, but so what? Gödel, Turing and von Neumann were very well aware that computation is a physical/philosophical concept described mathematically, not a purely mathematical one.
> Then let's not mention it, and stick to what can be dealt with mathematically.
But the definition of what is computable and what isn't depends on the Church-Turing thesis.
I'm not sure I understand your point. It is true that any computation can be modeled mathematically, but so can any other physical process. Also, computation does not require a specific physical implementation and is an abstract concept, but so what? Gödel, Turing and von Neumann were very well aware that computation is a physical/philosophical concept described mathematically, not a purely mathematical one.
> Then let's not mention it, and stick to what can be dealt with mathematically.
But the definition of what is computable and what isn't depends on the Church-Turing thesis.