Re:Reddit Is Being Manipulated by Big Financial Services Com...
by kneel on Thursday February 23, 2017 @11:34PM
(#13721035)
I really doubt wall street is spending hundreds of millions of dollars on equipment because they care about market liquidity. These people/services add absolutely nothing of value to society yet they suck up billions of dollars.
Very relevant:
I ask because I don't think that the case against HFT is airtight, or that either side is obviously right. A lot of smart people have defended HFT to some extent (including HN's favorite finance writer, Matt Levine[0]).
I get the sense that there are a lot of people out there who read Flash Boys and assumed that HFTs are obviously the bad guys. I'm something of a contrarian, and pointing out the arguments in favor of HFT to those people is the kind of thing I would have done. (I don't remember a particular instance, but I probably did at one point.) In that situation, I wouldn't be surprised if some people assumed that I was a paid Wall Street shill (because obviously that's the only kind of person who would defend HFT under any circumstances, right?)
So while I'm not denying that manipulation does happen, I'm worried that it will give people license to discount anyone that disagrees with their personal received wisdom as nothing more than corporate puppets.
[0] https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2014-03-31/michael-l...