The thing that scares me off the Android platform is the OS fragmentation. The sheer fact that I have to hack my device to upgrade it mind-boggles me. The fact that the G1 is not receiving what is becoming the greatest OS upgrade for the Android a mere 1.5 years after release is discouraging beyond the least.
Apple owns their stack top-to-bottom. They dictate how their devices are built, how carriers will work with them, and every aspect of the experience from start to finish. Comparing the G1 to the first iPhone on the basis of software compatibility ignores that Google and Apple operate in very different environments.
It should be ignored when comparing the devices. Consumers don't want to hear excuses for a flaw in the experience, they want the experience to not suck. Those environments are the result of very conscious choices by both organizations.
But agreed, the pre-3GS iPhone hardware frequently feels very laggy.
iPod Touch G1: 412 MHz G2: 533 MHz G3: 600 MHz, new processor
iPhone 2G: 412 MHz 3G: 412 MHz 3GS: 600 MHz, new proc (I assume), more RAM
From: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPod_Touch http://www.ilounge.com/index.php/articles/comments/the-one-p...
However, I do admit the loss of the 2G upgrade changes things a bit, and I would like to see how Apple handles it. The easiest answer is that the App Store allows one to select devices that are incompatible with certain builds, however I would love to see a universal binary situation supporting the old OSs much like PPC/x86 or iPhone/iPad apps.
At the OS-version level, you can build applications to take advantage of the latest OS, but also be compatible with earlier versions (that’s how the universal applications for iPad, iPhone, and iPod touch work—their base SDK is 3.2, while their target is set to 3.1.3 or below). Additionally, it’s fairly easy to detect whether or not a certain API is available at runtime.
When you open the market on a device it is pre-filtered to apps that work on your handset with your features, in your region, etc. Users don't have to read through and sigh at disclaimers.
Apps can even pre-filter by your screen size, whether you have a GPS, and so on.
The situation with Android is very similar to the Windows landscape: Lots of apps work perfectly fine back to Windows XP or before. Yet occasionally an app demands something particular on the newer variants so it becomes, for instance, Windows Vista+. Same idea with Android. That's just life of a quickly evolving ecosystem, and they've managed it well.
And remarkably many of the improvements have been ecosystem enhancements that benefit even apps target obsolete versions. The truth is that even today the platform API was so robust back on 1.6 (that was really the pivot point) that brand new apps still primarily target it.
I've been using a G1 for a year and the lack of quality apps for android (good design is rare) makes me want to pick up an iphone.
I've tried my coworkers Nexus One and its many times more usable than my G1 (pure speed) but it still lacks the apps and iPhone 4G will have comparable performance.
Everyone I've shown the EVO to -- including half a dozen Googlers who use Nexus Ones -- have been struck by the size of the screen and feel of using the phone. It's strong competition for the iPhone.
I've been using Android for awhile, and at least at this point, I've hardly ever found a lack of apps to be a problem. The only problems I've found are slowness (I have a sprint hero).
The main benefits I found to the iPhone (for me) are its speed and smoothness (esp. in the browser). The drawbacks thoug (for me) didn't make up for the gains (terrible notification system, lack of task switching, and lack of linux support).
In October 2008 I got a Google G1 the day it came out, replacing a tired Blackberry. This phone is the poster child for Android fragmentation, running a now-ancient version of the OS. But I could run most apps, and despite its relatively slow speed and limited non-SD memory, I believe it was the best alternative to an iPhone at the time.
Thanks to Google my new phone is an HTC Evo 4G. Same apps, same basic OS experience, only with the performance and phone features that make a G1 look like a toy. This is the platform I want: innovation as fast as possible on hardware and software at the same time. HTC is keeping up just fine and I'm betting developers will too.