Re:Wearable Fitness Devices Don’t Seem to Make You More Fit
by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @05:45PM
(#13709977)
> On the other hand relative step count (ie "I now go on more walks so I beat my own original levels of activity") is not entirely useless and probably has some non-zero value?
Relative step count is good if your only exercise is walking (or walking-like.)
OTOH, I've observed that my step count tends to go down as actual heavy exercise (weightlifting, etc.) goes up, so even relative step count isn't a good measure of overall activity.
> But, like, rewarding someone more for slowly strolling for 2000 steps vs running 1500 (which probably covers a similar distance and is waaaaaay better for cardio vascular fitness)
Its probably better for leg strength, but fitness walking (not casual walking), I suspect, is better for cardiovascular fitness, step-for-step, than running, since you get into a reasonably good exercising heart range for a longer time.
But, again, step counting alone doesn't distinguish fitness walking from casual walking any more than walking from running.
Relative step count is good if your only exercise is walking (or walking-like.)
OTOH, I've observed that my step count tends to go down as actual heavy exercise (weightlifting, etc.) goes up, so even relative step count isn't a good measure of overall activity.
> But, like, rewarding someone more for slowly strolling for 2000 steps vs running 1500 (which probably covers a similar distance and is waaaaaay better for cardio vascular fitness)
Its probably better for leg strength, but fitness walking (not casual walking), I suspect, is better for cardiovascular fitness, step-for-step, than running, since you get into a reasonably good exercising heart range for a longer time.
But, again, step counting alone doesn't distinguish fitness walking from casual walking any more than walking from running.