Re:U.S. Homeland Security employees locked out of computer n...
by jerf on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @08:03PM
(#13710762)
The existence of other vendors of the lowest grade of certificate does not mean that LE doesn't produce the lowest grade of certificate.
As I said, it is not a criticism of LE. It is simply what they are. It doesn't matter how we "feel" about that. It's not like the LE project set out to produce the highest grade of cert but failed; they accomplished exactly what they intended, and it is good.
Other issuers perform domain validation in the same ways (specific content at a specific URL, DNS records, e-mail validation, etc.) as LetsEncrypt. LE just makes it easier.
And, from a technical perspective, certificate X from issuer A is no different than certificate Y from issuer B (assuming both A and B are trusted root CAs, same key length, etc.).
If your issue is with DV vs. EV, yes, I agree that LE certs aren't on the same level as EV certs, but that's not the problem LE is trying to solve.