Re:Upspin – Another option for file sharing
by Merovius on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @02:48AM
(#13703923)
It's not a Google product. So no. (not that I'd agree with it not adhering to those roots currently. Just that this project has nothing to do with company policy)
Re:Upspin – Another option for file sharing
by driusan on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @08:57AM
(#13705485)
"This is the official list of people who can contribute
(and typically have contributed) code to the Upspin repository. The AUTHORS file lists the copyright holders; this file lists people. For example, Google employees are listed here but not in AUTHORS, because Google holds the copyright."
Re:Upspin – Another option for file sharing
by Merovius on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @01:30PM
(#13707822)
There is a difference between "a Google Product" and "Code to which Google holds copyright". Most importantly, the latter may include all code written by any Google Employee during their employment.
Re:Upspin – Another option for file sharing
by reitanqild on Thursday February 23, 2017 @10:07AM
(#13714405)
There is a difference but it is only interesting once you get really close like in a lawsuit IMO.
Google has copyright on the code and runs the infrastructure?
Very much a Google product to me. Paid or not. Official or not.
Re:Upspin – Another option for file sharing
by Merovius on Saturday February 25, 2017 @07:30PM
(#13734832)
But it makes a philosophical difference to the involvement of the company, of the people working on it and also a practical difference, because products and non-products have very different launch-requirements. You are perceiving Google as far more monolithic, than it really is; the difference between a product and a non-product is how different employees of the company interact. To the outside world, that might or might not have any meaning. But I feel for the original comment that I replied to, it does.
Re:Upspin – Another option for file sharing
by 4ad on Thursday February 23, 2017 @11:35AM
(#13715201)
From the docs:
> Terms of Service
> The Upspin website (the “Website”) is hosted by Google. By using and/or visiting the Website, you consent to be bound by Google’s general Terms of Service and Google’s general Privacy Policy.
Really a shame.
Is this an early sign of Google going back to its "not evil" roots or do I read too much into this?
Edit: for context, I used to be a google fanboy and I still to sone degree recommend some of their products. I just got a bit fed up with the butchering of xmpp and possibly a few things I can't remember right now.