That’s perfect for me. I hardly ever make calls but it’s still nice to have a phone number where others can reach you and since my university has great free WiFi, spending all that money on some 3G plan would be a real waste. I can nearly always just use my iPod touch.
In theory, nothing, but for those concerned about comitting to spending more than $5-10 a month on phone service (that is, the prepaid target market), spending $100-150 for a phone seems unlikely. And, in fact, I bought $10-15 phones repeatedly, about one a year on average, for the ~7 years I used prepaid-only. That was mostly with Virgin Mobile, though, which has no SIM, being a CDMA network.
I bought my £100 phone 2 years ago with £10 credit. Still got about £4 remaining on it (clearly I don't make a lot of calls). If I'd bought it on a contract I would be down double or triple what I paid.
Unfortunately AFAIK, you just plain can't get data plans with prepaid, from anyone. So prepaid doesn't work very well with smartphones. Also, T-Mobile coverage leaves a lot to be desired compared to other networks.
But my impression remains that if you buy a "prepaid phone", it will probably be very low quality.
On the plus side, if I had these problems with my current smartphone, I'd get it fixed, whereas with those, I just threw them away and got a new phone.