News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear Mark Zuckerberg: Democracy is not a Facebook focus g... by yeukhon on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @01:09PM (#13697800)
> In a country with functioning democracy, citizens vote responsibly because they know they will own the consequences if they don’t.

I never heard gerrymandering until after the 2016 election. It is scary how minority can still win the district election. So first fix that hole, and even getting rid of Electoral College, then we can talk about vote's value.

Cooperative platform seems to be a thing for this journalist. My reading is some socialism in this writing.

> would be to distribute that stock among the people who made it valuable in the first place: Facebook’s users. Like the British retailer John Lewis Partnership did for its employees, the stock could be held in a trust that users directly control and have the opportunity to benefit from.

I am going to say this is tough to do. Employee != users. Granted, there are fake accounts, how do you deal with that? You can't have a fake employee because that's a fraud.

> On the other hand, users might then have at least a seat in the boardroom when decisions are being made about what to do with their valuable, personal data now locked up in the platform.

Same argument above. Users can actually participate if they purchase stocks, but sure the entry cost is high.

I completely agree users should have influence in how a company runs and creates product, i.e. this is how a successful business should be, listen to users and take in the good advice. Let us supposed FB allows users to vote on features and how Facebook should run, then some malicious organization could create a lot of fake accounts to influence the outcome. Are we going to now required everyone to give out passport / proper government ID and verify our online status? Otherwise, how can you take these voting seriously? This is exactly what driving people away from Facebook the fact so many people are paranoid about their online privacy and identity. This is different from taking a user survey and asking WOULD YOU LIKE. Internet is fighting against fake news.

Until there is a solid solution, sorry, it's just idealism. The ideas are exciting but please give me a concrete implementation.

Re:Dear Mark Zuckerberg: Democracy is not a Facebook focus g... by ColanR on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @02:03PM (#13698455)
> It is scary how minority can still win the district election. So first fix that hole, and even getting rid of Electoral College, then we can talk about vote's value.

The electoral college is intended to give a fair say to minorities. It's a way to prevent a majority from completely overruling a minority.

Re:Dear Mark Zuckerberg: Democracy is not a Facebook focus g... by imw on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @05:55PM (#13700964)
As I understand it, historically speaking, the Electoral College was basically created to ensure the preservation of slavery as an institution.

For reference: http://time.com/4558510/electoral-college-history-slavery/

Re:Dear Mark Zuckerberg: Democracy is not a Facebook focus g... by yeukhon on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @02:17PM (#13698682)
I don't know the intent, but I think it is 2017 and we need to update our democracy. If voting is essential in democracy, and if people should value voting in democracy, then vote should count, not electoral college's vote. The existence of EC is basically asking employees if they want salary increase, so majority said yes, but the management holds the power to say no. In this case, the EC of each state is the powerholder.

Certainly in other democratic society the leader is elected from within a party after the majority party controls their version of Congress.

Re:Dear Mark Zuckerberg: Democracy is not a Facebook focus g... by tanderson92 on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @02:46PM (#13699120)
No, that is not true. It in fact was originally intended to protect slavery from the very electoral disadvantages (persons not eligible to vote, very many of whom were in the South) which slavery created[1].

http://www.rawstory.com/2016/12/the-electoral-college-was-ex...

Re:Dear Mark Zuckerberg: Democracy is not a Facebook focus g... by ColanR on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @02:55PM (#13699218)
I read your article. The author has nice primary citations, but ends up shoehorning his slavery agenda into quotations that don't support it.

Here's Wikipedia. I think we can agree it's a better source. Federalist Paper 68 describes explicitly why the electoral college was designed.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federalist_No._68#Hamilton.27s...

Edit: also, wikipedia addresses the slavery agenda just above where I cited it. Note the three fifths compromise, which benefited the slaveholding states under the EC, and the actual reasons for the EC given in the section I referenced.

Re:Dear Mark Zuckerberg: Democracy is not a Facebook focus g... by tanderson92 on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @09:35PM (#13702446)
Sorry, no, your link actually supports my point.

> The interests of slaveholding states may have influenced the choice of the Electoral College as the mode of electing the president. James Wilson proposed a direct election by the people, but gained no support and it was decided the president was to be elected by congress. When the entire draft of the constitution was considered, Gouverneur Morris brought the debate back up and decided he too wanted the people to choose the president. James Madison agreed that election of the people at large was the best way to go about electing the president, but he knew that the less populous slave states would not be influential under such a system, and he backed the Electoral College. Another factor here was the so-called Three-Fifths Compromise, which gave added power to the slaveholding states under the Electoral College which they would not have had under any likely form of popular vote.[1]

This is clear recognition that the electoral college was seen as amenable to the interests of the less populous slave-holding states. The 3/5 compromise increased the number of representatives for slaveholding states relative, and number of representatives is a factor in the number of electors to the college.

Moreover, simply because Hamilton claims something in a Federalist paper does not mean it was the only consideration in the support of an electoral college. Wikipedia (incidentally, no, I do not agree it is a better source at all) even supports this point by noting that Madison supported direct election, as did James Wilson and Governeur Morris. Madison noticed that the slaveholding states would not consent to such a method of election.

Your claim could not be more wrong and you are twisting the evidence to unequivocally deny an argument there is very real evidence for.

Re:Dear Mark Zuckerberg: Democracy is not a Facebook focus g... by wang_li on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @01:43PM (#13698183)
Gerrymandering is required by the voting rights act. An redistricting that changes the racial make up of a district can be challenged in court. So when demographics change over the decades, the districts have to be drawn in more and more convoluted ways so as to not disenfranchise a racial minority.
Re:Dear Mark Zuckerberg: Democracy is not a Facebook focus g... by germinalphrase on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @02:16PM (#13698663)
That is certainly one use of gerrymandering. Alternatively, it can be used to reduce the functional impact of minority votes to secure additional legislator seats for Republicans. This is the case in Wisconsin, though the prior redistricting maps have been found to unconstitutionally disenfranchise minority voters and must be redrawn before the 2018 elections.

Really, it's ridiculous that voting districts maps are drawn by political parties at all.

http://host.madison.com/wsj/news/local/govt-and-politics/jud...

Re:Dear Mark Zuckerberg: Democracy is not a Facebook focus g... by yeukhon on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @01:46PM (#13698219)
Gerrymandering is a practice of taking advantage of the redistricting requirement which can be banned. You can have Jerrymandering if you want.

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerrymandering