Randomly change the username on new posts from users that have a low average points per post (ppp)to a top 20 user in terms of ppp.
If there is no effect of username on ppp, then the difference between the users true average ppp and the randomly assigned one will be large, if there is an effect it will be approximately zero. We could test this statistically easily enough.
What say you pg?
If I did want to dismiss it I'd have said that HN possibly has a better attitude towards this than a random sample used in an experiment, but I figure HN is large enough now that such an effect if established as real will be present here too.
I really like the voting - it's good to know when you have said something stupid. Either everyone else is wrong or you are, and the latter is pretty unlikely :)
There are no words in the English language that should be dismissed with prejudice, but is one of those.
I'm not a 'native' speaker (or writer), the dutch for 'but' is 'maar', and it indicates a modification of the first part of the sentence, a qualifier.
It does not negate the preceding part but it detracts from it, so I mean that to read (and I'll try to avoid the use of 'but')
I take your word for the research, HN will have some of that that, given the general level of discourse here and having read extensively in both articles written by HN'ers and the comments I have yet to see your point proven but it is bound to be true to some extent.
Better like that? ;)
We are now quibbling over magnitudes, which is moot since there is no data either way.
Writing style apparently is not as easy to distinguish as we thought it was:
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1199592
and a follow-up:
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1203836
So the previously mentioned 'but we'll recognize people by their writing style if we obscure their ids' probably does not hold water.
And keeping (b) in mind, realize that it is often those opinions of an individual that conflict with the masses that contribute largely to the individual's greater-than-average success.
Whether or not you want your prestige to influence your statement credibility is entirely personal. I'd rather have it not effect it to keep myself honest.