News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff by jballanc on Saturday February 18, 2017 @02:39PM (#13676289)
This is far from the closest to launch SpaceX has called an abort. Many may not remember 3 years ago when they called the abort at T-1 after main engine ignition: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5v0k_0PTLnI

To be honest, though, neither case is really abnormal. There's a whole reason it's "T-minus" and "T-plus". T-zero is the point of no return (on the STS, this was when the solid boosters were fired). An abort at any point before then is still considered normal. Aborts after T-zero are anomalies.

(FWIW, even the STS has aborted take-off post-main-engine ignition: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8bkYP3pU76I . The main difference between the SpaceX Falcon and the STS is that the Falcon is capable of re-igniting its engines almost immediately, making a same-day re-attempt of a post-engine-ignition abort possible. The STS main engines require a manual reset, making abort post-engine-ignition more costly.)

Re:SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff by hcrisp on Saturday February 18, 2017 @06:57PM (#13677365)
It wasn't an abort, but the Mercury-Redstone 1 had a "T-plus" stop time [0]. It attempted to launch and the engine shut down immediately after lift off. It didn't explode, the escape rocket jettisoned, the capsule deployed its drogue, and the the rocket settled back on the pad untethered [1]. It came to be referred to as the "four-inch flight".

After considering some risky ways to deal with the fully-fueled rocket, flight control ultimately decided to wait until the LOX boiled off. Chris Kraft declared, "That is the first rule of flight control. If you don't know what to do, don't do anything."

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercury-Redstone_1 [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7O4V7JfeTSU

Re:SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff by teleclimber on Saturday February 18, 2017 @07:55PM (#13677585)
And if you like stories like that, "Failure is not an option" by Gene Kranz is a must-read/listen. It seems every single flight of the early American Space Program was a nail-biter.
Re:SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff by cbanek on Saturday February 18, 2017 @09:57PM (#13677968)
When you're responsible for it, or even a part of it, every moment is a nail-biter. You know exactly what can go wrong and how bad it could be.
Re:SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff by bisby on Saturday February 18, 2017 @02:58PM (#13676389)
I had found it odd, knowing that SpaceX ignites engines at T-2 (and releases clamps at T-0), watching the Arianespace launch earlier in the week. They ignited the main engine at roughly T-1, then revved it up until T+7, and then fired the solid boosters and released at T+8 or so. https://youtu.be/pgj0kSXEtdQ?t=890

The STS fired the solids at T-0, thus being the "point of no return", why is it that Arianespace waits until +8 to fire solids? Do they just consider igniting the liquid main stage as "no return" ?

Also, SpaceX had a T-1 abort after main engine ignition later too. (the one you showed doesnt even have landing legs!). The later one was SES-9 in Feb 2016 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LuS5mehCAMI

A boat was down-range and the cryo propellants had warmed up and started getting bubbles in it... the engines fire at T-2, run diagnostics, determine if they are running properly, THEN release clamps for lift off, but in this case, the bubbles caused lower than expected thrust, so it turned itself off.

Re:SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff by sitharus on Saturday February 18, 2017 @03:10PM (#13676443)
The Arianespace count is just a difference of opinion. The US space industry use T-0 as the moment of departure from the launch pad, whereas the European program uses T-0 as the moment of main engine ignition.

Ariane 5 has aborted after T-0 but prior to igniting the boosters, video here: http://www.space.com/11266-ariane-5-launch-aborted-engine-ig...

Re:SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff by JshWright on Saturday February 18, 2017 @03:09PM (#13676436)
An abort after T-00:02 was iffy for STS. If an abort was called after T-00:02, the RS-25s kept running until T-00:00 just in case the SRBs lit anyway.
Re:SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff by jballanc on Saturday February 18, 2017 @03:26PM (#13676507)
Makes you wonder why anyone ever thought it was a good idea to put solid boosters on a man-rated rocket...and yet NASA is repeating that "mistake" with the SLS.
Re:SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff by wolf550e on Saturday February 18, 2017 @04:08PM (#13676687)
It's a way to use NASA budget to prop up military contractor ATK.
Re:SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff by sand500 on Saturday February 18, 2017 @09:39PM (#13677904)
Not a problem this time because the capsule has a launch escape system
Re:SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff by JshWright on Saturday February 18, 2017 @09:57PM (#13677964)
A launch escape system which uses parachutes, which will not react well to descending through a cloud of burning solid rocket fuel...
Re:SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff by greglindahl on Saturday February 18, 2017 @04:04PM (#13676669)
Didn't Congress order NASA to do that, this time around?
Re:SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff by robryk on Saturday February 18, 2017 @07:20PM (#13677454)
I can't quite imagine what failure modes were they thinking about. Those failure modes must have had a nonnegligible chance of lighting off _both_ SRBs, but a very small one of lighting off a single SRB.
Re:SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff by jballanc on Saturday February 18, 2017 @08:40PM (#13677746)
IIRC, the SRBs generated enough thrust to break the hold-down bolts even in the event the frangible nuts don't fire. I'd guess the thinking is that, if both fire you might as well have the main engines running than not (since, as I noted before, the SSMEs couldn't be re-ignited in flight). True, if only one SRB fires, you're pretty much toast no matter what, but NASA loves their contingencies of contingencies of contingencies. For example, I've read that there were serious doubts that a Return-to-Launch-Site (RTLS) abort would actually, you know, be survivable, and yet it remained one of the official abort modes throughout the shuttle program.
Re:SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff by dotancohen on Sunday February 19, 2017 @02:14AM (#13678529)
In fact, there was at least one case (and maybe two, on consecutive launches), in which one of the serial SRB holddown bolts did not fire. The SRB, as designed, tore right through it.

Regardig RTLS, commander Young refused to test it on STS-1. Though it was engineered and had code and procedres written for it, RTLS was never really considered a viable option.

Re:SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff by JshWright on Saturday February 18, 2017 @09:25PM (#13677868)
I assume the very mechanism that ensured both lit also introduced the latency in the abort mechanism they were concerned about.
Re:SpaceX Halts Rocket Launch 10 Seconds Before Planned Liftoff by _delirium on Sunday February 19, 2017 @03:46PM (#13681877)
> FWIW, even the STS has aborted take-off post-main-engine ignition

This happened five times, in fact, all computer-initiated: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Shuttle_abort_modes#Redu...